Re:Show HN: Imagin Raw – A 9MB Open-Source Alternative to Ad...
by cristi_baluta on Tuesday July 21, 2026 @05:31PM
(#48998659)
That's some serious commitment there, i don't want to be responsible for people's files and i don't want to lock them into my software either. It seems to me highly inefficient to upload raws to a server then browse and edit online
Re:Show HN: Imagin Raw – A 9MB Open-Source Alternative to Ad...
by adyus on Thursday July 23, 2026 @06:26AM
(#49019374)
As the OP mentioned, seems inefficient to upload RAWs for processing and culling online. However, extracting and uploading the embedded or sidecar full-res JPEG, editing that non-destructively, then applying the edits to the offline RAW copy seems like it might work better.
Re:Show HN: Imagin Raw – A 9MB Open-Source Alternative to Ad...
by Toutouxc on Tuesday July 21, 2026 @02:56PM
(#48996537)
I’ll check this out. The macOS photo library situation is really embarrassing. I actually migrated from Affinity to DxO Photolab (expensive!) a few years ago just for that.
Re:Show HN: Imagin Raw – A 9MB Open-Source Alternative to Ad...
by cristi_baluta on Tuesday July 21, 2026 @03:02PM
(#48996609)
Unfortunately I have time to build only the software that I need, and I'm a Mac user. If I'd do a cross platform version it will end up like the other crappy cross platform apps out there.
Re:Show HN: Imagin Raw – A 9MB Open-Source Alternative to Ad...
by kmeisthax on Tuesday July 21, 2026 @03:47PM
(#48997255)
As someone who has had to use Creative Cashcow tools in the past... dare I ask what the hell was Bridge even for? Just an Adobe-developed file manager?
Re:Show HN: Imagin Raw – A 9MB Open-Source Alternative to Ad...
by hankbond on Tuesday July 21, 2026 @04:53PM
(#48998150)
I would argue that the choice to render the embedded JPG is optimal from the UX of a Fuji user. We tend to use the JPG as the creative reference we want to start from using the film sims.
Re:Show HN: Imagin Raw – A 9MB Open-Source Alternative to Ad...
by cristi_baluta on Tuesday July 21, 2026 @05:12PM
(#48998392)
Do you mean to show the jpeg when you have a raw+jpeg pair? I'm planning to add some options here in the next version, you'll be able to chose if to see both at once or only one and toggle between them
Re:Show HN: Imagin Raw – A 9MB Open-Source Alternative to Ad...
by hankbond on Tuesday July 21, 2026 @05:55PM
(#48998896)
RAF files contain (or at least can be configured to contain) a full size JPG embedded in them that will have the film sims baked in (as all JPGs do). You can use EXIFTools to extract them. Immich can be configured to make thumbnails off these embedded images instead of the demosaic'd RAF. I'm not sure if they are progressive JPGs but if they are I imagine it would be pretty efficient to directly read the images at a lower res and not even have to generate thumbnails (although that probably is less generalizable as a pipeline).
This is my current understanding and may be inaccurate.
Re:Show HN: Imagin Raw – A 9MB Open-Source Alternative to Ad...
by cristi_baluta on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @01:52AM
(#49002360)
Can you confirm that Imagin Raw does not display the previews with film simulations applied? There is only one embedded jpeg as far as i know, and i display that. If you toggle the zoom you can see a decoded version of the raw with nothing applied which looks totally different. I do not have a Fuji to do proper tests.
Re:Show HN: Imagin Raw – A 9MB Open-Source Alternative to Ad...
by cristi_baluta on Tuesday July 21, 2026 @05:07PM
(#48998348)
This is a type of software that can be feature complete quickly, so besides maintenance i don't see how long can you innovate. The nice thing though is that if the app disappears you go back to Bridge and you continue where you left off, you don't lose your ratings and labels and stuff.
Can you tell me about Affinity, what kind of integration? You can currently open a photo to edit in Affinity
Re:Show HN: Imagin Raw – A 9MB Open-Source Alternative to Ad...
by dofm on Tuesday July 21, 2026 @05:19PM
(#48998499)
Mainly I would like to see (if you don’t have it already) proper support for /previewing Affinity files (ideally the older .afphoto but I believe they are similar), and also Affinity layered TIFF, which I have used quite a bit.
I will test the app out soon. Best of luck with it!
Re:Show HN: Imagin Raw – A 9MB Open-Source Alternative to Ad...
by drumih on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @01:41PM
(#49010533)
Looks good!
Have you compared the image colors on the screen between your implementation and Adobe Bridge? Are they significantly different because of LibRaw, or is it not a problem?
Re:Show HN: Imagin Raw – A 9MB Open-Source Alternative to Ad...
by cristi_baluta on Thursday July 23, 2026 @01:03AM
(#49017155)
They look different, I display the jpeg preview backed into the raw, Bridge i believe decodes the raw and applies a default processing, they are more contrasty.
I’m building photopipe.app, a paid cloud-based culling tool, so I’m taking the opposite approach. Curious what made local-first important for you.
Seriously, what the hell are you talking about and why.
Has a lot of opportunity on the actual image rendering and performance side, but will definitely keep up with updates on how it evolves!
This is my current understanding and may be inaccurate.
So I am sure to try this. I’d love to see closer integration with Affinity where that is possible.
I will test the app out soon. Best of luck with it!
Have you compared the image colors on the screen between your implementation and Adobe Bridge? Are they significantly different because of LibRaw, or is it not a problem?
Thanks!