News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The FreeBSD Foundation falls short of its 2012 fundraisin... by lmm on Monday December 10, 2012 @05:57AM (#4898483)
>The phrase "vanilla Linux" doesn't even make sense. Linux is a kernel, not an operating system. If you're talking about the entire GNU/Linux operating system, it doesn't make sense to talk about a "vanilla" version, because there are thousands of different utilities that can comprise a GNU/Linux-based operating system, and there are combinatorially many ways to create a Linux distribution.

The point is, when it breaks and you need someone to help you fix it, it's often not enough to find someone else who "uses Linux" - you need to find someone else who runs the same distribution, because they all have their own init scripts, packaging systems, filesystem layouts etc.

By contrast, because there is a single FreeBSD, anyone who "uses FreeBSD" can probably help you with your FreeBSD problems.

(Of course, if you choose a popular linux like Ubuntu, there are probably many more people who "use Ubuntu" than use FreeBSD)

>This is vastly exaggerated. A properly compiled binary or a compatible source file should run on any distro - not just any modern distro, but any older one as well (assuming that it has the correct dependencies installed, etc.).

Seriously? I don't think I've ever seen a cross-platform binary that worked without distro-specific hackery. Source sure.

>If I wanted to get really snarky here, I'd say that the same thing could happen to BSD too and point to OS X. This is just ridiculous - Linux is open source and free-as-in-freedom, so just because somebody else packages your favorite distro with some stuff you don't like doesn't mean that anybody else has to as well

You're right - but there is some truth to the generalization that linux distributions a) rush in software before it's truly stable (Debian stable being the exception that proves the rule) b) are more politicised than FreeBSD. The recent Gnome 3 / Unity fuss would be unthinkable in FreeBSD-land. In the time it's taken Linux to go OSS -> ALSA -> PulseAudio (and say what you like but I know several people whose sound broke with each of those) FreeBSD has stuck with OSS. Linux introduced devfs, encouraged users to migrate, then deprecated and killed it off in the space of about 18 months (in favour of udev); FreeBSD has only ever had one devfs. FreeBSD ships binary compatibility going back to at least version 5, while very few linux distributions still ship glibc5 libraries. In FreeBSD I've never had a driver that used to work stop working (under linux I used the qc-usb driver, which then stopped building against newer kernels; also the drivers for my PDA (sc-somethingorother)).

Re:The FreeBSD Foundation falls short of its 2012 fundraisin... by chimeracoder on Monday December 10, 2012 @11:34AM (#4899818)
> The point is, when it breaks and you need someone to help you fix it, it's often not enough to find someone else who "uses Linux" - you need to find someone else who runs the same distribution, because they all have their own init scripts, packaging systems, filesystem layouts etc.

Again, greatly exaggerated. I'm usually able to use Ubuntu or Fedora forums to help solve my problems, even though I don't run a Debian-based distribution. If I'm having systemd problems, I can debug that the same way as with any system running systemd, whether it's Fedora, Red Hat, Arch, etc. If I'm having issues with my package manager, I can use resources from any distro that uses that same package manager.

You're assuming that these variations cause combinatorially many possibilities for problems, but in reality, Linux is designed to be modular enough that these things don't compound in practice.

That's not even taking into account that most Mint issues have the same solutions as they would on Debian/Ubuntu, etc., because most distros are derived from one of a small set of distros; very few start 'from scratch'.

> By contrast, because there is a single FreeBSD, anyone who "uses FreeBSD" can probably help you with your FreeBSD problems.

Yes, but NetBSD and OpenBSD? Not so helpful. And frankly, given the relative sizes of the Linux and BSD userbases, this isn't really a problem on Linux at all.