News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Claude Fable produced a counterexample to the Jacobian Co... by beering on Monday July 20, 2026 @12:33AM (#48974363)
I think parent’s point is that every false conjecture can cost a lot of time to be spent on futile affirmative proofs. So if we “clean up” a bunch of false conjectures, then more effort can be spent on interesting proofs of the others. (Probably a rather naive view of the value of conjectures but I’m just offering an alternative interpretation of the comment.)
Re:Claude Fable produced a counterexample to the Jacobian Co... by nommynommynom on Monday July 20, 2026 @03:09AM (#48975237)
The opposing argument there is that the hope is that solving these problems reveals other interesting maths knowledge along the way. Finding a counter example all but ensures that won't ever happen.
Re:Claude Fable produced a counterexample to the Jacobian Co... by c32c33429009ed6 on Monday July 20, 2026 @04:59AM (#48976071)
No, it opens up a whole new suite of questions. Now we can ask, for example: what conditions do we need for the result to hold? What dimensions does it hold in? And many more...
Re:Claude Fable produced a counterexample to the Jacobian Co... by pegasus on Monday July 20, 2026 @05:55AM (#48976532)
I guess the question of why counterexamples are so rare and/or hard to find is still left to be investigated.
Re:Claude Fable produced a counterexample to the Jacobian Co... by jibal on Monday July 20, 2026 @07:08AM (#48977146)
Did you read what you responded to? The Collatz conjecture is almost certainly not false, so no "clean up" is possible.
Re:Claude Fable produced a counterexample to the Jacobian Co... by aleph_minus_one on Monday July 20, 2026 @07:11AM (#48977174)
> The Collatz conjecture is almost certainly not false, so no "clean up" is possible.

Many people believed the same about the Jacobian Conjecture.

Re:Claude Fable produced a counterexample to the Jacobian Co... by jibal on Monday July 20, 2026 @09:57PM (#48987190)
non sequitur
Re:Claude Fable produced a counterexample to the Jacobian Co... by jibal on Wednesday July 22, 2026 @01:22AM (#49002187)
P.S. Also false -- it simply is not true that many people believed that the Jacobian conjecture was almost certainly not false--why would they? OTOH, the Collatz conjecture has been confirmed for all integers up to 2.36 *10^21, and Terence Tao has proved that it is true for "almost" all numbers: https://www.quantamagazine.org/mathematician-proves-huge-res...

Again, this is all non sequitur, because the context was a statement that most mathematicians believe the CC to be true, in which case there would be no "clean up".

Re:Claude Fable produced a counterexample to the Jacobian Co... by aureate on Monday July 20, 2026 @03:07PM (#48983436)
The Collatz conjecture is a question about positive integers, so enumerating and checking all the possible counterexamples is trivial, albeit requiring infinite time. It has been verified up to 2.36×10^21. It could turn out to be false, but nobody's going to find a counterexample as surprisingly simple as the one Claude found for the Jacobian conjecture, which would be like finding a Collatz counterexample in the first few billion integers or so.

... Or would it? The Jacobian counterexample seems like an especially simple, near-trivial integer-coefficient polynomial, but I haven't seen any thorough analysis of how "hard" it would have been to find by brute force, and I haven't seen Claude's reasoning.

Re:Claude Fable produced a counterexample to the Jacobian Co... by orangecat on Tuesday July 21, 2026 @12:18PM (#48994397)
I haven't seen any thorough analysis of how "hard" it would have been to find by brute force

Pretty hard. I asked Fable and it gave an estimate of 10^46 candidates in the counterexample's "reference class", and that's assuming you know how many distinct terms there are (as opposed to searching all polynomials of degree 7/6/4 for the three coordinates, which it estimates at 10^334).