News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chris Wanstrath's Startup Riot keynote text by kragen on Friday February 20, 2009 @09:15PM (#489573)
I wrote:

None of these three items are necessarily true of "having a descriptive title on a Web [sic] site".

Peter Cooper responded:

Why not? Having a properly worded title could...

There is a difference between what could be the case and what is necessarily the case. It is certainly true that having a descriptive title on a web page could be marketing. My claim was that it was not necessarily marketing, and in fact need not satisfy any of those criteria.

Peter Cooper wrote:

With your criteria you could argue that Ruby on Rails (the original topic a few posts up) could not possibly be "marketed"...

You could argue that if you were an idiot. But you would still be wrong.

Peter Cooper wrote further:

Take the word "financially" out ... and nearly all communications is marketing.... most day to day discourse is not honest...the majority of conversation has that quality.

Actually, a substantial fraction of human communications are not, in fact, attempts to dishonestly manipulate someone else's opinions for the personal gain of the speaker. I understand that you may not be aware of this, but I assure you that it is true.

By the way, I love Github.

Re:Chris Wanstrath's Startup Riot keynote text by petercooper on Friday February 20, 2009 @09:23PM (#489579)
-sigh-

There I was thinking this was a reasonable discussion and it gets dragged down to a childish "yah boo well you're just wrong" level. Fine, you "win" :)