Re:The Folly of Scientism
by lotharbot on Saturday December 08, 2012 @06:37PM
(#4893128)
I was most struck by the line that "It easily becomes an interpretive blank check, permitting speculation that seems to explain any describable human trait." This has long been a criticism "real" evolutionary scientists (like geneticists) have leveled against the speculative nonsense often seen coming from sociobiology/evolutionary psychology [0].
Science works to find scientific conclusions. But the trappings of science are sometimes applied in ways that have little to do with actual science.
Science works to find scientific conclusions. But the trappings of science are sometimes applied in ways that have little to do with actual science.
[0] http://www.newyorker.com/arts/critics/books/2012/09/17/12091... -- note that sociobio/ev psych can produce real science. In my experience, though, most of what they produce is "just-so stories", as Gould's comment points out.