Re:The Folly of Scientism
by droithomme on Saturday December 08, 2012 @07:35PM
(#4893285)
It has been asked whether science yields "better or more accurate answers" than other approaches.
We know that most published scientific research results are wrong.
http://www.plosmedicine.org/article/info:doi/10.1371/journal...
Therefore flipping a coin and always guessing "heads" yields more accurate results than science.
Now what? Has this insight taught us anything?
That's a sweeping over-generalization. More like "many inferences based on statistics are not as strong as they appear to be many are not even true". That article is important (and well known) for a certain type of life sciences publications; it's a problem that is being addressed already. That's another good thing about science, you can measure how wrong you are.
Re:The Folly of Scientism
by thirdtruck on Saturday December 08, 2012 @10:31PM
(#4893666)
And how did that research come to the conclusion that most research comes out wrong? Statistically-rigorous research.
Second: it remains a question of degree. Most preliminary medical research, for example, suffers from heavy biases, but it remains far more predictive than the "alternative medicine" beliefs that are more than 90% incorrect.
Ethical questions cannot not really be answered by science cause that would be an appeal to nature. Some evo-psychologists may claim otherwise, but i think he's right about their narrow utilitarian position.
Re:The Folly of Scientism
by AffableSpatula on Saturday December 08, 2012 @06:32PM
(#4893112)
Is it better to classify a rabbit by its meat or by its fur? It depends what you want to do with it.
Regardless of whether one agrees with him or not, his argument makes NO sense to me. The relevant question is not whether science can have all the answers, but whether science yields better or more accurate answers than those other approaches.