News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hacking Meat: Can technology make us eat fewer animals? by ComputerGuru on Saturday December 08, 2012 @12:07PM (#4892021)
What is it with this modern obsession with not eating meat?

Meat is good. It's healthy, it's very sustainable, it's got an incredible protein:volume ratio, and it's delicious.

Re:Hacking Meat: Can technology make us eat fewer animals? by xiaoma on Saturday December 08, 2012 @01:03PM (#4892209)
Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. And some of your claims are extraordinary.

>What is it with this modern obsession with not eating meat?

It's not a "modern obsession". Varying degrees of vegetarianism have been part of human culture since ancient times. People, especially Americans, are eating far more meat than they did 50 or 100 years ago. There is a greater variation, but the mean is definitely rising.

>Meat is good. It's healthy

Meat consumption (particularly red meat and processed meat) has been linked to higher rates of cancer, cardio-vascular disease, and overall mortality in a dose dependent manner. Furthermore, some vegetarian populations are extremely long-lived compared to the their omnivorous peers.

>it's very sustainable

Meat eating is not sustainable at our current technological level. Mass production of animals to be slaughtered for our consumption accounts for the majority of human-caused methane production, causes the majority of anti-biotic resistant disease, requires many times the energy expenditure that growing plant-based foods do and is an enormous threat to bio-diversity.

If all the world ate as much meat as Americans, it would be a disaster in terms of public health and the environment both.

>* it's got an incredible protein:volume ratio,

Protein != intrinsically good.

>and it's delicious.

Taste is subjective, but a lot of people would agree with you.

Re:Hacking Meat: Can technology make us eat fewer animals? by duaneb on Saturday December 08, 2012 @02:19PM (#4892422)
There's a big difference between eating meat and eating meat like the modern american does. Eating meat every day and being vegetarian are far from the only options.
Re:Hacking Meat: Can technology make us eat fewer animals? by bendmorris on Saturday December 08, 2012 @12:47PM (#4892164)
Very sustainable?

"Food production requires application of fertilizers containing phosphorus, nitrogen and potassium on agricultural fields in order to sustain crop yields. However modern agriculture is dependent on phosphorus derived from phosphate rock, which is a non-renewable resource and current global reserves may be depleted in 50–100 years."

Raising animals to eat is a much less efficient use of non-renewable phosphate than eating plants ourselves.

Source: Dana Cordell, Jan-Olof Drangert, Stuart White. 2009. The story of phosphorus: Global food security and food for thought. Global Environmental Change, Volume 19, Issue 2, Pages 292-305.

http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0959378008...

Re:Hacking Meat: Can technology make us eat fewer animals? by Turing_Machine on Saturday December 08, 2012 @03:17PM (#4892572)
The phosphate doesn't actually get used up. It winds up back in the ocean from whence it came (most phosphate rock is limestone formed from krill and the like).

There's no reason we couldn't use krill directly. It would be more expensive, but also 100% renewable.

Re:Hacking Meat: Can technology make us eat fewer animals? by bendmorris on Saturday December 08, 2012 @03:34PM (#4892599)
We don't really have the infrastructure in place for doing that at the necessary scale, so it would be so much more expensive as to cause food prices to skyrocket. I'm sure that as supplies get lower more research will be done on recycling phosphate efficiently, though.
Re:Hacking Meat: Can technology make us eat fewer animals? by Turing_Machine on Saturday December 08, 2012 @03:37PM (#4892605)
You don't need a lot of infrastructure. Krill nets are pretty low-tech.

Also, it's not like we're going to wake up one morning and all the phosphate rock is gone (which is the usual unstated assumption with "peak" this or that). The price will go up gradually until the point where alternative sources become more economic.

Re:Hacking Meat: Can technology make us eat fewer animals? by Turing_Machine on Saturday December 08, 2012 @03:51PM (#4892661)
For that matter, you could probably create engineered organisms that do a better job of extracting the phosphate from seawater. Animal kidneys are pretty good at this already.

Before we were able to process phosphate rock on an industrial scale, animal waste was the primary source of agricultural phosphate and nitrate. There was a thriving industry in mining bird droppings (guano) from various islands all through the 19th century. The birds would eat the sea life, concentrate the minerals, and deposit them on land. There's no reason we couldn't cut out the middle man (or middle bird, in this case).

Re:Hacking Meat: Can technology make us eat fewer animals? by HorizonXP on Saturday December 08, 2012 @02:19PM (#4892421)
I'll bite.

Meat, and red meat in general, has got a bad rap because of various studies linking it with poor health (i.e. cancer and cardiovascular issues).

Personally, I would argue against it. We know from anthropology studies that humans only evolved to our current state because we started to eat larger quantities of meat. Fact is, there is no better source of nutrition and calories when you're looking at foods obtainable from the environment.

In the 20th century, we're in a different situation. Food and calories are easy to come by, to the point that many Westerners are gluttonous and we eat too much. We don't need to eat meat to obtain more calories, removing it as a requirement from our diets.

Vegetarians will argue that their diets have less of an impact on the planet, and that they're healthier overall. You can argue that point either way, but anecdotally, I've met few vegetarians that are actually "healthy." Many do not understand that if you remove meat as a source of protein, you need to supplement it with another source. Vegetarian sources of protein are not very protein-dense, so you need to eat a lot of food to get your daily requirement. Moreover, you need to ensure that you're obtaining all of your essential amino acids, which many plant-products don't provide. That's why Indians, a predominantly vegetarian society, will eat rice with daal. Rice lacks lysine, which daal contains. Together, they are a whole source of protein.

I've personally tried the vegetarian diet, and it's not for me. It's not for everyone. I found that to hit my protein requirements, I had to eat a lot of carbohydrates along with it, which meant a lot of calories.

Right now, I'm overweight, so I'm trying to hack my diet and lose weight in a completely different way. I eat absolutely no carbohydrates. All I eat is lamb (I'm Hindu, so no beef or pork), fish, and poultry. I also eat lots of green vegetables, nuts, mushrooms, and cheeses. Oh, butter and heavy cream too. It's called the ketogenic diet if you're interested.

I've never felt better. No intestinal issues or bloating. I'm losing weight steadily. And I get to eat awesome, healthy meals that taste amazing. And I would bet that my environmental impact isn't all that high. My grocery list is very simple, sticking to the outer corridors of the store.

It's not for everyone. But it works for me. I would bet that most studies that say red meat is bad, didn't control for carbohydrates. The biochemical processes that occur in the body in reaction to carbohydrate intake is likely what contributes to the issues surrounding red meat. Of course, few studies have been done to confirm this because of a general disposition that high-fat diets are bad.

In summary, people are against meat because they keep hearing that it's bad. They don't seek out alternate opinions, and would rather be ignorant than educate themselves.

Re:Hacking Meat: Can technology make us eat fewer animals? by bendmorris on Saturday December 08, 2012 @03:13PM (#4892562)
I'm on keto too. But people do have valid, non-health reasons for avoiding meat, including ethical and sustainability concerns. Keto is great for your own personal health, but in some ways people who choose to incorporate large amounts of meat into their diets (like you and I) are basically choosing these personal benefits over the greater good for everyone else.
Re:Hacking Meat: Can technology make us eat fewer animals? by HorizonXP on Saturday December 08, 2012 @03:46PM (#4892647)
Depends on how you look at it though. If you keep your view narrow (not meant as an insult), you're right, our impact on the environment and economy via agriculture is probably higher. Fact is, an animal requires more nutrients and care to raise than a plant. That takes a lot of energy and resources.

If you expand your view, you can actually begin to argue that we might have a reduced impact in comparison to others. There is anecdotal and limited empirical evidence that suggests that people that strictly follow a low-carb diet actually have better blood chemistry that those on a low-fat diet. Lower LDL cholesterol and triglycerides, and higher HDL cholesterol levels usually lead to a reduced risk of cardiovascular disease. Not to mention that it's practically impossible to have diabetes. Those on a low-carb diet are usually trying to lose weight, so that helps too, since maintaining a "normal" weight has wider health implications.

My point is that being overweight likely has a larger impact than simply eating meat. Being overweight, you're more likely to have higher healthcare costs, eat more, and require more energy and resources to sustain. If you're lighter, most of these negatives go away. Whether you achieve your lower weight by low-carb or low-fat doesn't really matter. But there are plenty of people that eat low-carb as an actual lifestyle, and their blood chemistry generally indicates that they're healthier overall.

Anyway, to each their own. But this fallacy that meat-eaters are creating an unethical and unsustainable environment is specious. You really need to look at the big picture.

(I wish I had actual sources to cite.)

Re:Hacking Meat: Can technology make us eat fewer animals? by luser001 on Saturday December 08, 2012 @03:43PM (#4892634)
> (I'm Hindu, so no beef or pork)

Minor nit: I don't think Hindus are prohibited from eating pork. AFAIK.

> And I would bet that my environmental impact isn't all that high.

Ironically this page claims that lamb is the worst of all meats wrt CO2 footprint.

http://ewg.org/meateatersguide/eat-smart/

Re:Hacking Meat: Can technology make us eat fewer animals? by HorizonXP on Saturday December 08, 2012 @03:51PM (#4892660)
Regarding pork, you're right, and I knew that. Just the way I've been raised and at this point, it's become more of a personal choice. Plus, makes it easier to hang out with my Jewish and Muslim friends. :-P

Also, I've thought about that for lamb, since it's such a small animal compared to pigs and cows. It's partly why it's so expensive. However, I bet a lot of that impact is because very few lambs are raised in the US, and most is imported from New Zealand and Australia. Since I'm in Ontario, Canada, that's less of an issue for me since most of my lamb is raised locally.

In fact, my fiancee's brother-in-law is Greek, and during Orthodox Easter, they go up to a farm, pick a lamb, have it slaughtered, and bring it back to roast on a rotisserie. (If you can ever do this in your life, do it!) So the carbon footprint is probably as low as it's going to be here in Ontario.

Re:Hacking Meat: Can technology make us eat fewer animals? by ahelwer on Saturday December 08, 2012 @12:32PM (#4892118)
That's overly simplistic and you know it. There are pretty obvious ethical issues. Not that I really want to start a discussion on them, because if there's anything more played-out on the internet than the piracy debate it's the meat-eating debate.

That in addition to how inefficiently the nutritional value of giant animals is generated.

Disclaimer: I eat meat.

Re:Hacking Meat: Can technology make us eat fewer animals? by nathos on Saturday December 08, 2012 @12:36PM (#4892129)
Also, it it truly sustainable? The demand for low-cost animal protein has in part led to increased factory farming, antibiotic use, growth hormone use, etc.

(I'm also a meat eater, but I eat less beef than I once did, largely because of cost & health concerns)

Re:Hacking Meat: Can technology make us eat fewer animals? by Yaggo on Saturday December 08, 2012 @01:07PM (#4892222)
I'm not even going to mention the horrendous ethical issues of meat production industry, but sustainable?

"[...] current production levels of meat contribute between 14 and 22 percent of the 36 billion tons of "CO2-equivalent" greenhouse gases the world produces every year."

http://www.scientificamerican.com/article.cfm?id=the-greenho...

Re:Hacking Meat: Can technology make us eat fewer animals? by blahedo on Saturday December 08, 2012 @12:36PM (#4892130)
Meat (or rather, animals) also consume a lot more resources to produce the same amount of available-nutrient output. I'm a meat-eater too, and I agree with your assessment, but it's a little disingenuous to pretend that vegetarians have no reasons for their actions.

(Also, IME there are as many reasons to be vegetarian as there are vegetarians---they all have a slightly different answer.)

Re:Hacking Meat: Can technology make us eat fewer animals? by Turing_Machine on Saturday December 08, 2012 @03:19PM (#4892575)
"Meat (or rather, animals) also consume a lot more resources to produce the same amount of available-nutrient output."

Depends on how it's raised. Grain-fed meat, sure. Grass-fed meat, not so much. People can't digest grass.

Re:Hacking Meat: Can technology make us eat fewer animals? by luser001 on Saturday December 08, 2012 @03:52PM (#4892665)
https://www.google.com/search?q=percentage+of+grass+fed+beef

Only 3% of beef in the US is grass-fed. For chicken, the equivalent would be "pastured", and I bet it far less than 1% (I've never seen it for sale in supermarkets and I know you have to join a coop or something to get it).

Re:Hacking Meat: Can technology make us eat fewer animals? by exodust on Saturday December 08, 2012 @03:43PM (#4892633)
There's nothing in this article about "not eating meat". The whole point is that meat can be grown in the lab, so you can eat it all you like then.

Meat comes from animals who have pretty miserable lives up until death in the modern factory farm. and then the environmental stress from feeding and transporting livestock is huge. And the protein health benefits comes with some warnings not to eat too much meat! Raw meat is dangerous too, causes much sickness annually. Left over chicken, oops don't touch that.

Tastes great though, so let's grow the world's meat in big vats and the cow can have a well earned vacation. Fair?

Re:Hacking Meat: Can technology make us eat fewer animals? by davidp on Saturday December 08, 2012 @03:47PM (#4892651)
Well,

> "... the hackathon’s goal is to come up with technological answer to the problems of meat supply, processing, distribution, health and ultimately consumption. One of big problems the group will tackle is how — simply put — to get people to eat less meat."

That said, it's true that meat production (beef at least) is a very inefficient use of arable land, in terms of nutrition per acre.

Curse their tasty hides.

Re:Hacking Meat: Can technology make us eat fewer animals? by exodust on Monday December 10, 2012 @10:51PM (#4902942)
Yes you're right, I missed that bit. Quite interesting that "butchers, farmers, and food industry executives" would be tackling the "problem" of getting people to eat less meat! Perhaps they are vegetarian butchers.
Re:Hacking Meat: Can technology make us eat fewer animals? by guygurari on Saturday December 08, 2012 @04:02PM (#4892683)
Others have already answered, but to address the health issue allow me to mention a credible source [1], written by one of the leading experts on the relation between nutrition and health. The word 'vegan' appears only a couple of times in this book, but what it advises approaches veganism, based on purely decades-long research.

The research shows that more than a little meat is not healthy (unless you have no better alternative), and there is no harm in not eating meat at all.

[1] http://www.amazon.com/Eat-Drink-Be-Healthy-Harvard/dp/074326...

Re:Hacking Meat: Can technology make us eat fewer animals? by stcredzero on Saturday December 08, 2012 @12:51PM (#4892177)
> Meat is good. It's healthy, it's very sustainable, it's got an incredible protein:volume ratio, and it's delicious.

I had been doing the low carb thing recently, so I agree with most of this. Unfortunately, the relative scarcity of meat in our history has resulted in our wanting to eat too much of it for our health.

That said, imbalances in our global civilization's distribution of food is a much bigger problem than calories per acre. (I guess one could argue that realistically we need to produce an overabundance of food to compensate.)

Re:Hacking Meat: Can technology make us eat fewer animals? by naner on Saturday December 08, 2012 @04:52PM (#4892818)
There are a lot of motivations for discovering ways to synthetically produce meat. Cheaper and easier to make, higher yield, better nutrition, better taste, consistent quality, etc. I don't think the ethical considerations are the driving force.
Re:Hacking Meat: Can technology make us eat fewer animals? by diminish on Saturday December 08, 2012 @12:55PM (#4892187)
"Meat is the biggest thing you can steal from some creature, it kind of destroys her presence, and discontinues her future. meat-eating is killing for theft of the functional body.".

Every organism must collect their energy, aminoacid, vitamins themselves rather than stealing from their peers. I am against all eating including eating of vegetables, honey etc and critical of the current earth-based life.

when designing the post-humans we must exclude "eating" for body build-up and energy intake.