Re:Show HN: For 10 World Cups, my model's 2 favorites had th...
by swiftcoder on Wednesday July 15, 2026 @08:31AM
(#48919843)
It predicts likely winners based on the round of 32 performance (plus prior data). That's still "prospective" with respect to the finals
Re:Show HN: For 10 World Cups, my model's 2 favorites had th...
by glimshe on Wednesday July 15, 2026 @08:58AM
(#48920178)
Which is very reasonable. You estimate odds after seeing teams playing with the actual squad selection at that period in time. Otherwise I'd dismiss the predictions as lucky guesses in a row.
Re:Show HN: For 10 World Cups, my model's 2 favorites had th...
by derdi on Wednesday July 15, 2026 @08:39AM
(#48919952)
Yes. I don't like phrasing this as being prospective for the World Cup as a whole. It's for the knockout stage. (Which the abstract says! But the title doesn't.)
Re:Show HN: For 10 World Cups, my model's 2 favorites had th...
by kunxue on Wednesday July 15, 2026 @09:12AM
(#48920358)
The baseline matters here: favorites win World Cups all the time. How often would "always pick the two pre-tournament favorites" have gotten the champion in these same 10 tournaments? Without that comparison, 10/10 tells us basically nothing.
Re:Show HN: For 10 World Cups, my model's 2 favorites had th...
by decimalenough on Wednesday July 15, 2026 @09:26AM
(#48920541)
France was far and away the pre-tournament favorite for 2026, if anything it's somewhat impressive that OP's model correctly predicted that they wouldn't make it.
Here's hoping they were right for England as well, but we'll find out soon enough.
Re:Show HN: For 10 World Cups, my model's 2 favorites had th...
by fabioricardo7 on Wednesday July 15, 2026 @07:20PM
(#48928491)
That was exactly the point I was trying to make in this preprint. I appreciate your comment.
Seems weird to wait to run the "prospective" simulation until the World Cup is already in progress. Although it seems that the model also needs to use "the actual bracket and group-stage performance". So it's not prospective?