News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The New Pornographers by DanielBMarkham on Friday February 20, 2009 @03:10PM (#489154)
The tone of this article is "just let kids be kids, okay?"

I agree with the tone.

The nagging part is the fact that "kids being kids" never included making media of their naked selves doing sexual stuff before. Media which can easily be distributed to millions, including some very sick people. Media which can last a lifetime (or longer)

Sure, we smoked pot when we were kids, and we read Playboys too. But nobody has videos of us doing all of that on YouTube. The electronic records problem here is extremely disturbing.

With the current FB conflict, I'm sure that most adults don't realize what kind of electronic record they're leaving all over the place, much less their kids. As a society, we've generally tried to protect kids from doing things that could have lifelong consequences. Do we want to give that up?

The underlying philosophy is a tricky-wicket. We don't necessarily allow kids to do stuff simply because "kids will be kids", i.e., it's natural for them to do it. So while I'm all with the emotion of the article, the underlying issues are a lot trickier than I think the author lets on. You can't just skim over the fact that 30 years from now when you're applying to be Supreme Court Justice that videos of your 14-year-old self doing stupid people sex tricks could be out there circulating. Fair or not, people aren't going to understand.

Re:The New Pornographers by asdflkj on Friday February 20, 2009 @07:05PM (#489447)
Actually, people are going to understand, because they'll have grown up in the world of MySpace and cellphones themselves. To a generation still alive, it would be unthinkable to admit in public that one has smoked pot and "read" Playboys, and yet you've just done it, and your career is unlikely to be harmed.

That "very sick people" bit gives away your true motivation for these opinions, though.

Re:The New Pornographers by jerf on Friday February 20, 2009 @08:07PM (#489515)
You are advocating the position that people will be rational about seeing videos that speak to our animal core selves.

I don't buy it. Even if people intellectually realize that a stupid sexy video made when you are 18 is no big deal, it will still unavoidably color people's opinion of you, and there isn't a damned thing you can do about it except make sure they can't get that video in the first place.

Re:The New Pornographers by asdflkj on Friday February 20, 2009 @08:48PM (#489552)
If porn speaks to your "animal core self", I envy you. It stopped doing that to me around age 15.
Re:The New Pornographers by DanielBMarkham on Saturday February 21, 2009 @12:38AM (#489681)
That "very sick people" bit gives away your true motivation for these opinions, though

So you're attacking my motivation instead of my comment?

Nice.

If I understand you correctly, you're saying that there are not very sick people in the world? In addition, you're also saying that people act the same way towards public figures as they would to a close friend?

Got any examples of this benevolent social behavior? Because I'm thinking we went about 80 years after the prohibition of pot before we allowed a president who admitted using it. It was accepted practice to deny it, because guess what? People are hypocrites about the way they treat public figures. They always have been that way. Sounds like this is coming as a news flash for you.

I'm still trying to figure out what my true motivation is. Somehow I managed to give it away and I don't seem to remember having one (besides curiosity with the topic)