In the UK there's a close-in-age exception for anyone under 16 (the legal age is 16). Canada just last year changed their age of consent to match, moving the AoC up to 16 from 14.
This is just a simple equation I use in my head to figure out if a relationship is creepy-weird when dating and it's quite simple. Here's my example, (21 - 13) / 2 = 4, so in this instance a 21 year old can date a 17 year old or a 25 year old without the age difference being weird. It seems to hold up for most 'accepted' relationships, including the like 80 year olds married to the 50 year olds, but not the 80 year olds married to the 20 year olds that people find disgusting.
Personally I'd say it's okay for 12-13 year olds to have sex with 12-13 year olds because as a culture we seem to be subconsciously pushing for it. 14 and over I'd say the close-in-age exceptions apply well, a 14 year old can have sex with someone within 5 years of their own age without it being a crime and over 16 you have the right to choose who and how you do it, although I wouldn't disagree with a law making a bigger close-in-age for 16-18 of like 10-15 years. It's socially accepted that a couple are usually within a 10-15 year age difference of each other.
The problem, as my parents explained to me when I was younger, isn't that you're not physically ready, because after adolescence starts you're physically primed for sex. The problem is that before you've matured to a certain degree, you're not mentally ready to handle hormones, and while I think that's completely fine between, say, two high school kids who lust after one another, once you're in your 20s and you realize that these younger children are easily taken advantage of, then your using that is despicable.
While I think better sex ed would help a lot, I agree with the current age of consent in the U.S. Eighteen means you're old enough not to be taken in by somebody as easily. The rules about child porn need to be changed, because becoming a sex offender over "sexting" is stupid, but the rules about having sex make logical sense to me.
your age > (her age / 2) + 7
So:
if you're 16 she should be at least 14
if you're 20 she should be at least 17
if you're 30 she should be at least 22
if you're 50 she should be at least 32
These all seem to fit nicely into the acceptable ranges. Doesn't work too well if you're under 14 though :-)
younger_person >= (older_person / 2) + 7
it has the added advantage that it proscribes anyone younger than 14 ever having sex (with anyone of any age) since the inequality could never be satisfied.For example if the older person was 12, then the younger person would have to be at least 13, which is impossible.
I have a 28-year old friend who has an 18-year old girl, there's no problem there, so this rule doesn't always apply.
I don't think 12 is an unreasonable number. I had a pretty good understanding of sex at 12... so it would be dumb to put me in jail for having sex at that age.
OTOH, I could see how pressuring a 12 year old to consent (and not tell anyone about it) could be pretty easy... and that's not good. (FWIW, people over 18 are also pressured into sex they don't really want, so I am not sure how to deal with this.)