Re:A letter to the TEDx community on TEDx and bad science
by greenyoda on Saturday December 08, 2012 @03:14PM
(#4892565)
"It's basically impossible for people outside the scientific community related to a specific field to independently test or verify extremely progressive science in that field..."
That's not necessarily true. For example, a statistician may not know anything about biology or medicine, but she could prove that a paper in a biomedical research journal was worthless by showing that the authors didn't get statistically significant results or made errors in their statistical computations.
Or someone with no knowledge of the field at all could notice that a paper that was cited as a supporting reference for a claim had been later withdrawn by its authors after being busted for scientific misconduct.
I can understand why an organisation like TED would prefer to err on the side of false positives over true negatives when it comes to their bullshit detector.