News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A letter to the TEDx community on TEDx and bad science by skylan_q on Friday December 07, 2012 @12:37PM (#4888047)
What also bothered me is the notion that consensus determines what's good science. (If we all agree to something, then it must be true!)
Re:A letter to the TEDx community on TEDx and bad science by Symmetry on Friday December 07, 2012 @12:42PM (#4888080)
Good science isn't identical to the truth. Rather, science is a social process whereby large groups of imperfect humans with their various vanities and weaknesses can eventually converge on the truth. Someone might come up with an idea that happens to be true, but until it's tested it isn't good science - and we have easy way to know it's true.
Re:A letter to the TEDx community on TEDx and bad science by fatbird on Friday December 07, 2012 @12:54PM (#4888144)
For a popularizer of science, sticking to current consensus is fine, and a good way to avoid promoting pseudoscience. No one's claiming TEDx is the last word on these topics, or on science in general, and if they accomplish nothing more than making mainstream science more accessible, that's pretty good by itself.
Re:A letter to the TEDx community on TEDx and bad science by Aykroyd on Friday December 07, 2012 @12:48PM (#4888113)
Right. It's a tricky line to walk. But the TedX name grants a certain level of mainstream acceptance to ideas. And it seems like they're trying to prevent people from taking advantage of that to pimp their latest miracle, effort free, libido enhancing, hair increasing, bicep growing treatment.

An earlier comment mentioned that it's a question of what's the right forum to debate new ideas. Going to direct to the public is probably not the right one. Another hallmark of these hoaxes tends to be the notion that "main stream scientists don't want you to know" etc... It's trash.

I wish the letter had ended by admitting that it's tough to exactly define bad science but it's a lot like porn, you know it when you see it.

Re:A letter to the TEDx community on TEDx and bad science by nollidge on Friday December 07, 2012 @01:32PM (#4888393)
What do you propose as a superior alternative?
Re:A letter to the TEDx community on TEDx and bad science by rscale on Friday December 07, 2012 @12:57PM (#4888164)
Scientific consensus isn't "we believe"; it's "the results of widespread, independent, carefully executed, controlled experiments show."

Further, it doesn't mean that it "must be true" but rather that it is more likely to true.

Re:A letter to the TEDx community on TEDx and bad science by jacoblyles on Friday December 07, 2012 @02:44PM (#4888868)
That's not quite true. Many branches of science don't use controlled laboratory experiments.
Re:A letter to the TEDx community on TEDx and bad science by lutusp on Friday December 07, 2012 @02:54PM (#4888919)
Yes, but all legitimate sciences (a) put forth falsifiable theories, and (b) abandon those theories that fail comparison with reality.

The fact that cosmologists don't perform laboratory experiments with miniature black holes doesn't reduce the scientific standing of cosmology, as long as there are equally persuasive sources of evidence to support the theories.