News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ubuntu Spyware: What to Do? by Shamanmuni on Friday December 07, 2012 @10:44AM (#4887365)
Personally, while I generally agree with rms, in this particular situation I think he went overboard. Not in expressing his opinion, but in the way he did it.

I say this as a free software advocate; this situation arises from a sad reality, and one that rms doesn't even address: it's really hard to make money from free software. I don't think Mark Shuttleworth was enthusiastic about sending users' information, the deal with Amazon is just a way to try to monetize an OS which its users mostly don't pay for.

So, instead of rallying the people to boycott Canonical, rms should be more understanding of the situation. After all, the Free Software Foundation is well aware of the difficulties of obtaining money in this space. Have you noticed that the three biggest patrons of the FSF are companies whose money comes largely from non-free software? I'm talking about Google, Oracle and IBM. What does it tell us about the free software movement. https://www.fsf.org/patrons

We are close to 2013, many years ago, when I started using Slackware Linux, I would have expected that by this time there would be many thriving companies offering free software solutions for the desktop and competing for my money based not on lock-in, but on quality and innovation. Where's my flying car?

I understand and completely support the "respect user's privacy" argument, but we should also understand the "money doesn't fall from trees" argument and seek acceptable solutions, otherwise the year of Linux on the desktop will never come.

Re:Ubuntu Spyware: What to Do? by acabal on Friday December 07, 2012 @10:53AM (#4887417)
I think RMS's stance is by definition always the extreme. He sees these things in black and white, so there's no degrees of compromise. If software phones home with private information without the users explicit consent, it's against his principles, period. And I think that's an excellent position to have, which is not to say you're not right either--making money is an important and difficult aspect of FOSS. But the day that RMS starts compromising will be a sad day.
Re:Ubuntu Spyware: What to Do? by niels_olson on Friday December 07, 2012 @11:53AM (#4887806)
Agreed, RMS essentially has as his sole professional obligation to the community to explore, stake out, and shine a light on a very deontologic position. It is a lonely camp and it wouldn't hurt us to put some rice in his bowl.
Re:Ubuntu Spyware: What to Do? by zanny on Friday December 07, 2012 @11:10AM (#4887518)
He kind of already has given ground, saying Steam on Linux is borderline acceptable at times.
Re:Ubuntu Spyware: What to Do? by mixmastamyk on Friday December 07, 2012 @03:03PM (#4888963)
Having a failed business model doesn't make spying on users ok.
Re:Ubuntu Spyware: What to Do? by cjg on Friday December 07, 2012 @02:03PM (#4888590)
RMS doesn't care if Canonical make any money.