Re:Cargo-nextest: 3x faster than cargo test, per-test isolat...
by trollbridge on Thursday July 09, 2026 @02:29AM
(#48841759)
This is from the Kubernetes saying of "treat servers like cattle, not pets". Of course, some people like me keep cattle as pets, but then again I also name my servers, even the virtual or containerised ones.
Re:Cargo-nextest: 3x faster than cargo test, per-test isolat...
by sunshowers on Thursday July 09, 2026 @02:33AM
(#48841776)
Yeah that was indeed the inspiration (though I'm pretty sure it predates Kubernetes!) but the juxtaposition with "terminate" is unfortunate.
Re:Cargo-nextest: 3x faster than cargo test, per-test isolat...
by wojciii on Thursday July 09, 2026 @03:13AM
(#48842041)
I liked the way it was phrased. You can't make everybody happy. :)
Re:Cargo-nextest: 3x faster than cargo test, per-test isolat...
by seanhunter on Thursday July 09, 2026 @05:41AM
(#48843308)
It’s a horrible saying in that context also.
Re:Cargo-nextest: 3x faster than cargo test, per-test isolat...
by embedding-shape on Thursday July 09, 2026 @07:28AM
(#48844152)
I mean, I like animals too, but in context it does make sense. The context was to treat them as "obtainable yet ultimately killable entities you keep as a group, not individuals", which cattle pretty much is. Unless you consider keeping cattle as draft animals, but I think that stopped being the main purpose a long time ago.
It got the point across, at a time where most people basically acquired servers, kept them until they died, and he was trying to push a development workflow where you constantly close("kill")/bring up new servers.
Re:Cargo-nextest: 3x faster than cargo test, per-test isolat...
by entrope on Thursday July 09, 2026 @09:20AM
(#48845390)
IMO, "make your servers fungible" is a better way to express the intent: slightly shorter, no metaphors, although "fungible" is a less common word. Maybe that's just me. (Edited to add: "make your tests fungible" has I think the wrong connotation; I think the original wording on the blog is about test executions -- and "make your test executions fungible" does seem like a good goal, similar to ACID guarantees for database transactions.)
Re:Cargo-nextest: 3x faster than cargo test, per-test isolat...
by embedding-shape on Thursday July 09, 2026 @09:38AM
(#48845661)
Before that, I used to call them "ephemeral", and of course half the people asked what "ephemeral" means, probably "fungible" would be met with similar question, unless the crowd is cryptocurrency-adjacent, that term seems understood there.
Re:Cargo-nextest: 3x faster than cargo test, per-test isolat...
by jen20 on Thursday July 09, 2026 @09:08AM
(#48845248)
That (unpleasant) saying predates Kubernetes by at least half a decade.
Re:Cargo-nextest: 3x faster than cargo test, per-test isolat...
by nixosbestos on Friday July 10, 2026 @11:32PM
(#48868456)
Who here is old enough to know about PetSets, since we're talking this topic and k8s...
Re:Cargo-nextest: 3x faster than cargo test, per-test isolat...
by sunshowers on Thursday July 09, 2026 @02:29AM
(#48841753)
That's fair! I'll find a way to rephrase it.
edit: Updated to "Detect and handle slow tests". Thanks again!
Re:Cargo-nextest: 3x faster than cargo test, per-test isolat...
by mhluongo on Thursday July 09, 2026 @08:17AM
(#48844666)
It resonated with me!
Re:Cargo-nextest: 3x faster than cargo test, per-test isolat...
by Zababa on Thursday July 09, 2026 @08:35AM
(#48844916)
Fungible/non fungible is a good alternative, and maybe the technically correct word. But I think in that case it doesn't apply and the change the author did is better.
Re:Cargo-nextest: 3x faster than cargo test, per-test isolat...
by 27183 on Thursday July 09, 2026 @10:32AM
(#48846537)
"Treat tests as annuals not perennials"
"Treat tests as workers not management"
Re:Cargo-nextest: 3x faster than cargo test, per-test isolat...
by moi2388 on Friday July 10, 2026 @07:43AM
(#48858601)
Jesus Christ do we seriously need to limit our speech and get rid of perfectly good analogies for every special little snowflake?
Re:Cargo-nextest: 3x faster than cargo test, per-test isolat...
by sunshowers on Friday July 10, 2026 @07:13PM
(#48866549)
Like all things in life, there is a balance :) I didn't remove the cattle vs pets analogy but I did replace "terminate" with "handle".
>Treat tests as cattle, not pets. Detect and terminate slow tests.
Not sure saying, "hey, treat your tests as an animal you can kill at will" paints the right image.