did anyone actually look at this:
http://yelp.typepad.com/.a/6a00d83452b44469e2011278fa14eb28a...
the favorite review is clearly marked. seriously - if the claims of reviews disappearing maliciously are true then sure let's hang yelp from the gallows. i do know for a fact that they're quite aggressive about anti-spam for being such a large site.
the fact is they've had such a positive effect on my life that i'm willing to actually hear the other side.
So shenanigans or not, IMHO Yelp is still a valuable resource.
I too don't really see a problem with a clearly marked, "highlighted" review. If Yelp is dropping bad reviews in exchange for sponsorship (or worse, writing fake bad reviews), I would take issue.
does anyone on HN actually use yelp? have you guys ever talked to a small business person who's had interactions with yelp?