Re:Rayfish, Peer-to-peer mesh VPN with no server to trust
by keepupnow on Sunday July 05, 2026 @01:46PM
(#48796218)
It is wrong to describe these P2P products as server-less. In order to connect two peers over WAN it needs a form of coordination server. Since Rayfish appears to be a Claude coded wrapper over Iroh it should at-least give credit to use of Iroh's discovery and relay nodes.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Rayfish, Peer-to-peer mesh VPN with no server to trust
by throwawaypath on Sunday July 05, 2026 @05:57PM
(#48798326)
>Since Rayfish appears to be a Claude coded wrapper over Iroh it should at-least give credit to use of Iroh's discovery and relay nodes.
But that would take understanding network fundamentals, architecture, etc. Who needs any of that cruft any longer?
Re:Rayfish, Peer-to-peer mesh VPN with no server to trust
by keepupnow on Sunday July 05, 2026 @08:04PM
(#48799255)
Lol thats right who needs this now we have gpt duh
Re:Rayfish, Peer-to-peer mesh VPN with no server to trust
by dfish on Monday July 06, 2026 @09:46AM
(#48804520)
We do have understanding of networks. Claude doesn't come up with concepts by itself. It is not too good to do that yet.
We run an HFT firm as a main enterprise, not an easy job. Requires a lot of network fundamentals understanding.
Re:Rayfish, Peer-to-peer mesh VPN with no server to trust
by jarym on Sunday July 05, 2026 @11:24PM
(#48800320)
Iroh can use multiple discovery methods, one of them is DNS. When a node comes online it publishes its addresses[1]. Another node can resolve from the node id those addresses and attempt a direct or hole-punched connection. If that works, relays aren't needed.
So agree not serverless, but also does not NEED a coordination server (unless you class DNS as a coordination server which is debatable).
[1] https://docs.iroh.computer/concepts/address-lookup#endpoint-...
Re:Rayfish, Peer-to-peer mesh VPN with no server to trust
by dfish on Monday July 06, 2026 @09:44AM
(#48804497)
Hello! dev here.
Yes, we did use claude, somewhat. We do give a lot of credit to iroh. Check the description of the repo.
As per the AI stuff, rayfish is a very old idea. I had a lot of sketches on how a p2p mesh VPN should look like. So it started off as "hey claude, can you do this?" and of course because I use it I have to do a lot of things manually myself.
But of course, without iroh this project would have not been possible!