News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: My 13 year-old cousin hacked into his school's sy... by tptacek on Thursday February 19, 2009 @04:10PM (#487860)
Like most of ESR's aphorisms, this "building vs. breaking" thing misses the mark entirely, reflecting more about how ESR thinks about the world than how the world actually works.

There is lots of productive work to be done in "breaking" systems. Nobody thinks Arjen Lenstra or Paul Kocher are doing work of a lesser caliber than Alan Cox; it is (I think obviously) harder to break RSA than it is to build a new Linux virtual filesystem layer. It is only because people like ESR don't know about people like Paul Kocher that this "build vs. break" meme spreads. Let's try to kill it when it appears.

What teenagers need to have is a sense of ethics. This has nothing to do with whether you spend your time finding holes in things, and everything to do with respecting property, with not assuming that you know the impact of every action you take that invades someone else's property, and hopefully with having a productive goal.

Here's what you need to tell your cousin: nobody in the real world gives a shit about your ability to break into one computer system. Per-host network penetration testing is close to the bottom rung of the computer security career ladder. If he likes breaking things, what he should do is start picking up open source software, researching how it works, finding vulnerabilities, and reporting them.

He's going to find really quickly that knowing you could --- if you were a criminal and a moron --- break into tens of thousands of computer systems is a lot more fun than breaking into one badly-configured school computer. He's also going to learn real computer science, because really breaking systems involves really reading and understanding code, runtimes, layering, information modeling and representation, and any of a zillion other things.

Computer security is a really awesome tour of a lot of the fun stuff in a CS curricula. I've worked on compilers, crypto math, distributed commit protocols, filesystems, and language runtimes in just the last 12 months. If he likes this stuff, get him to stay with it.

You asked for books. How about:

* The Web Application Hacker's Handbook (bad title, great book).

* Eldad Eilam's "Reversing"

* The Art Of Software Security Assessment (our industry's bible)

* The Shellcoder's Handbook

* The last 10 years of Black Hat Briefings talks, which are all available online.

There are no comments on this comment yet.