News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Short Leash AI Coding Method for Beating Fable by delusional on Friday July 03, 2026 @01:35AM (#48771192)
> While deterministic, there is not a fixed number of ways it can express itself, given that we can use settings like temperature to inject randomness into the output.

You're missing the point, which is that no matter the process involved. The LLM can only ever output one of the tokens in its token vector. It can't invent a new symbol or character. It can't leave and go build a church. It has to output a little piece of data for you.

Re:The Short Leash AI Coding Method for Beating Fable by infinite_spin on Friday July 03, 2026 @04:48AM (#48772555)
You're moving the goalpost. If the definition of intelligence is based on ability to "go build a church", then we've ruled out the vast majority of the animal kingdom from being labeled "intelligent". If you cannot be consistent in your definition of "intelligence", then you cannot have a reliable litmus test for it.
Re:The Short Leash AI Coding Method for Beating Fable by delusional on Friday July 03, 2026 @10:25AM (#48775458)
I wasn't trying to make a reliable litmus test for it.

Either way, if you consider animals, LLMs are even more poorly positioned. They can do exactly none of the things my cat can do. An LLM can string together words, but if my cat is intelligent, it's clear that stringing together words is not synonymous with intelligence, since my cat can't do that.

Re:The Short Leash AI Coding Method for Beating Fable by infinite_spin on Friday July 03, 2026 @04:00PM (#48779270)
Animals do in fact "string words together", e.g. parrots. You're also misidentifying what "language" is. Language in this context is not just the ability to string word together. Consider a musician, when they learn to play an instrument, they are learning the language of that instrument. Notes are tokens, ensembles are sentences and paragraphs. I'm afraid you're experiencing conformational bias, because every piece of evidence presented to you has been dismissed with things like "stringing together words is not synonymous with intelligence, since my cat can't do that".