Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi...
by malnourish on Wednesday July 01, 2026 @07:45AM
(#48745189)
The United States has always dealt with this - the North Virginian voters circa 1960 were not, by and large, indigenous.
Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi...
by like_any_other on Wednesday July 01, 2026 @07:57AM
(#48745297)
> The United States has always dealt with this
Did you mean to write "America" instead of "the United States"? Because when the continent had only American Indians, there was no United States. And in fact for a long while after it was founded, they were excluded from citizenship.
Regardless, I'm sure we both agree that European conquest and colonization represented a giant change. It's false to imply that another such change isn't a change, by virtue of it happening once before already. Or to imply that therefore, the country is compelled to submit to such a change.
Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi...
by malnourish on Wednesday July 01, 2026 @07:33PM
(#48754513)
If I wanted to be that pedantic, I could have looked up one of the many words for the land the displaced indigenous peoples used.
Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi...
by like_any_other on Thursday July 02, 2026 @08:08AM
(#48760170)
It's not pedantic to distinguish between a landmass and a nation.
Re:Supreme Court upholds broad conception of birthright citi...
by malnourish on Friday July 03, 2026 @04:46PM
(#48779768)
touche, but metonymy is an accepted part of the English language.
Mass immigration also builds a new country little by little. As just one example, election results would look very different if the US still had 1960s, or even 1980s demographics. Per the New York Times:
Not long ago, this rolling green stretch of Northern Virginia was farmland. Most people who could vote had grown up here. And when they did, they usually chose Republicans. [..] Unlike three decades ago, the residents are often from other places, like India and Korea. And when they vote, it is often for Democrats. - How Voters Turned Virginia From Deep Red to Solid Blue, https://www.nytimes.com/2019/11/09/us/virginia-elections-dem... (https://archive.is/Vwll8)
It's more accurate to say the new country has already been built, and they are trying to restore the old one.