News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Best Replacements for Privacy-Invading Services by jmillikin on Tuesday December 04, 2012 @02:29PM (#4872767)
The site says you shouldn't host your private data on certain free services because they show you ads, so they recommend instead using free services that don't show you ads?

Come on HN, you know how this works. If a service doesn't show you ads, and doesn't charge a monthly fee, how do you think they make money? Either they're not, so they'll go out of business when their VC funding runs out, or they're selling whatever they can glean about your habits to third parties.

---

Additionally, the article conflates two very different concerns under the banner of "privacy".

If you object to advertising, then many free services also have some sort of paid tier. Send then $5 a month and they stop showing you ads. Problem solved.

If you're concerned about third parties having access to your data, then your only practical options are to either host everything on a computer you own, or encrypt your data before it leaves your desk. Both options are significantly more complex than using free hosting, but can provide stronger guarantees about the safety of your data.

The advantage to encryption is that you can decide on a file-by-file basis whether it's important enough to protect. Maybe you're OK with Dropbox/Google/Box.net/etc being able to see pictures of your cat, but don't want them to see your tax documents or medical records.

Of course, the main problem with taking security seriously is that you are placing yourself into a very small, difficult-to-please market segment. Most companies will find it easier to simply ignore you, so they can make their products work better for people who don't particularly think about data security.

Re:The Best Replacements for Privacy-Invading Services by dmlorenzetti on Tuesday December 04, 2012 @04:23PM (#4873335)
The site says you shouldn't host your private data on certain free services because they show you ads, so they recommend instead using free services that don't show you ads?

This is an unfair characterization of the reasoning in the article. The main point isn't whether or not a service shows you ads. For example, the suggested e-mail provider, Lavabit, shows ads to certain classes of users.

Rather, the point is whether the service sells your information to advertisers, or mines your information-- including the contents of any messages you send via the service. Often this data mining is done in order to target advertisements at you, but the targeted ads, per se, are not the point.

For example, the main objection to Google Search isn't that they use the information to target advertisements (it even admits that doing so may allow Google to serve you more useful ads). Instead, the stated rationale for using DDG is "if you're worried about the amount of data collected on your browsing habits..."

Others on this discussion have pointed out that a lot of people are willing to make that exchange (trade off a little privacy in exchange for a good service). That's fair. But the article is clearly written for those who want to limit the inspection and selling of their personal information, not those who want to avoid advertising.

Oddly, the second part of your post shows that you understand the distinction. But I think any conflation of the two (advertising and privacy) is in your reading of the article, not in the article itself.

Re:The Best Replacements for Privacy-Invading Services by jmillikin on Tuesday December 04, 2012 @05:15PM (#4873586)
Why do you feel that targeted ads are more privacy-invasive than untargeted ads? They're both "selling you to advertisers", the only difference is that one option will show you ads for things you want and the other for things you don't. Either way, the site will record that the ad was viewed, and whether you clicked it.
Re:The Best Replacements for Privacy-Invading Services by dmlorenzetti on Tuesday December 04, 2012 @06:36PM (#4873977)
First of all, my point wasn't about what I feel. It was about the intent of the article (or, if you prefer, my reading of the article's intent).

That said, in my reading of the article, the point isn't that targeted ads invade privacy more than untargeted ones. Rather, it's the act of mining your personal information that is the invasion of privacy. The fact that your information is read in order to target ads is almost beside the point.

Here's a concrete example from my own life (and now I do bring in my own feelings). Shortly after my wife found out she was pregnant, we started getting flyers in the mail for baby-related products. As nearly as I could figure at the time, the information could only have come from two sources: (1) my credit card (invading my privacy by telling companies I was starting to buy baby-related products); or (2) Facebook (invading my wife's privacy by selling information she posted for her family and friends to read).

After reading this article, I see that a possible third source was Gmail (invading my privacy by scraping the content of messages I wrote to my friends and family).

Now I understand people who say "That's OK, you got a free credit card in exchange for them selling your buying habits to companies." And I understand people who say "That's OK, your wife got a free Facebook account in exchange for them selling her posts to companies." And I understand people who say "That's OK, you get a free e-mail product in exchange for them reading the content of your private messages."

What I don't understand is any notion that it's not an invasion of privacy, because I might want to learn about baby-related products.

To put it in even more concrete terms, here are three forms of advertising for baby-related products:

(1) I see a billboard advertising infant formula.

(2) I buy an issue of "New Parent" magazine and see an ad for infant formula inside.

(3) I write an e-mail to my brother saying "Guess what, we're having a baby!" and five days later a sample pack of infant formula shows up on my doorstep.

Each of these advertisements is progressively more targeted. The first and second do not invade my privacy, while the third does. And the thing that bothers me is not that the advertising is targeted. It's that the advertiser is even aware that I'm a potential target.

Re:The Best Replacements for Privacy-Invading Services by jmillikin on Tuesday December 04, 2012 @06:49PM (#4874039)
You're assuming that Facebook or Google sold your private data to third parties. While this is theoretically possible, it is unlikely, for both practical and ethical reasons.

I notice you say you bought baby-related products with your credit card. This provides a more likely explanation: statistical analysis of consumer buying habits by retailers (doesn't even have to be the card company) can reveal many sorts of information.

The particular example of pregnancy has been well-covered, see http://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/19/magazine/shopping-habits.h... and http://consumerist.com/2012/02/17/target-figures-out-teen-gi... .

As for your examples: I'd say that while #1 and #2 are targeted advertisements, #3 is not an advertisement, it's straight-up espionage.

[deleted]
Re:The Best Replacements for Privacy-Invading Services by jmillikin on Tuesday December 04, 2012 @05:28PM (#4873666)

  > A targeted ad network needs to log/know more about you,
  > in order to actually target the ad.
An untargeted ad network needs to know generally the same things, to mitigate fraud and inform advertisers about the size/demographics of viewers.

People seem to believe an ad network that selects ads randomly is more trustworthy or less privacy-damaging than one that selects ads based on the current page or current viewer, which is a belief I consider unreasonable.

Re:The Best Replacements for Privacy-Invading Services by alexkus on Tuesday December 04, 2012 @03:03PM (#4872968)
> The site says you shouldn't host your private data on certain free services because they show you ads, so they recommend instead using free services that don't show you ads?

> Come on HN, you know how this works. If a service doesn't show you ads, and doesn't charge a monthly fee, how do you think they make money? Either they're not, so they'll go out of business when their VC funding runs out, or they're selling whatever they can glean about your habits to third parties.

I've said this before but I'd love to see some people doing not-for-profit versions of major services. Some advertising, but just enough to pay salaries and costs but not return 10x to investors (which you wouldn't get in the first place). No founders cashing out with $1bn+ payoffs after IPO, no IPO, no funding rounds, just a bunch of employees that would be treated fairly and collecting a safe regular salary/benefits with no expectation of a huge payoff.

If only I had made my millions in order to fund such an endeavour...

Re:The Best Replacements for Privacy-Invading Services by ApolloRising on Tuesday December 04, 2012 @03:30PM (#4873092)
That is pretty much Craigslist
Re:The Best Replacements for Privacy-Invading Services by rhizome on Tuesday December 04, 2012 @03:31PM (#4873099)
An interesting b-school paper would measure the financial effect of well-known unprofitable companies registering 501(c)3.
Re:The Best Replacements for Privacy-Invading Services by pdonis on Tuesday December 04, 2012 @05:02PM (#4873517)
Some of the services referred to in the article are not free; they make money the old-fashioned way, by charging users for services provided (at least for some level of service).
Re:The Best Replacements for Privacy-Invading Services by cs702 on Tuesday December 04, 2012 @04:24PM (#4873338)
The best replacements would be local applications under one's full control that seamlessly sync all data on a peer-to-peer network encompassing all of one's devices -- desktop PC, tablet, phone, etc. Alas, AFAIK, such applications don't exist yet.

The next-best replacements would be paid services that work with all of one's devices, but transmit and store one's data only after it has been encrypted, with the private keys fully under one's control. Alas, AFAIK, such services don't exist yet.

As a compromise, I would pay for a decent integrated alternative to Google's Gmail, Contacts, and Calendar that doesn't use my private data for anything else and works across all of my devices (Linux desktop, tablet, phone). Alas, AFAIK, such an alternative doesn't exist yet.

Only a tiny number of people today care enough about their privacy to worry about it, so companies have no financial incentive to do much in this regard (except as required by law).

Re:The Best Replacements for Privacy-Invading Services by amirmc on Tuesday December 04, 2012 @06:32PM (#4873958)
> The best replacements would be local applications under one's full control that seamlessly sync all data on a peer-to-peer network encompassing all of one's devices -- desktop PC, tablet, phone, etc. Alas, AFAIK, such applications don't exist yet.

This is the kind of thing we're working on (http://perscon.net). It's a open-source effort, currently happening through academia. That gives us the luxury of solving some tricky problems without the pressure to 'lash something together' (though academia has other issues).

Privacy conscious software will eventually reach the masses but I've no idea how long it'll take. I also believe it needs to be created from the ground up if it's really meant to care about your privacy. An open question is how such software can be commercialised, since the economic incentive is currently around 'Big Data', and people don't want to manage their own infrastructure. Both of these push us towards more centralised services.

DEspite this, nearly everyone I speak to seems wary of how much companies like FB/Google "know about you" but people just accept the data-leakage almost as a cost of engaging online.

Re:The Best Replacements for Privacy-Invading Services by jrabone on Tuesday December 04, 2012 @05:19PM (#4873604)
Yes, that is exactly what I want. I rooted and upgraded my S2 to a Cyanogen 10 nightly over the weekend (trying to fix the seemingly un-interoperable Android VPN implementation for my setup) and I was appalled to realise that one of the things I was losing was a local calendar and contacts provider - apparently that was something Samsung added, and vanilla Jellybean is cloud-only. I don't WANT my contacts phone numbers in Gmail. I don't even want Gmail, really; it's a fall back and a throwaway don't-trust-you-with-my-real-email account.

I run my own mailserver (Exim + Courier IMAP/POP servers). Is there a good server-only contacts & calendering system written in a sane language (I refuse to use PHP, life is too short) I can add? TLS support a must. Anyone fancy writing one plus the Android integration?

Re:The Best Replacements for Privacy-Invading Services by alextingle on Tuesday December 04, 2012 @06:29PM (#4873948)
I do fancy writing that actually. Sadly I'm busy for the next year or two but after that, this is one of the problems I would love to help solve.
Re:The Best Replacements for Privacy-Invading Services by icebraining on Tuesday December 04, 2012 @05:08PM (#4873548)
ownCloud seems to be going in that direction. Contact and Calendar syncing on Android is "in development".
Re:The Best Replacements for Privacy-Invading Services by JoshTriplett on Tuesday December 04, 2012 @01:52PM (#4872569)
For email, I personally prefer Gandi; if you have a domain with them, they provide email servers, and they have webmail if you want to use that instead of (or in addition to) an email client. Plus, that way I get email at my own domain rather than at someone else's, so I know that email address will keep working forever even if I change providers.
Re:The Best Replacements for Privacy-Invading Services by martey on Tuesday December 04, 2012 @02:53PM (#4872913)
The original article is about replacing GMail with a more privacy conscious service. Lavabit was mentioned because they use encryption to protect email from premium accounts.

Doing some cursory research, I was unable to find information about how Gandi secures your email messages. Their terms and conditions - http://en.gandi.net/static/contracts/en/gandimail/pdf/specia... - do not make it much clearer, and contain some weird language:

By accepting Our Contracts and using Our services, You agree to abide to Our code of ethics which consists, in particular, of protecting and respecting minors, human dignity, public order and good moral standards, not infringing on the rights of third parties (private life, image, honor and reputation, trademarks, designs and models, copyrights, etc.) or the security of persons, property, the government, or the good working order of public institutions, and to help in the fight against abusive and/or deviant uses of the Internet (spamming, phishing, hacking, cracking, or attempts at hacking or cracking), or any other infraction as cited in the Penal Code.

Re:The Best Replacements for Privacy-Invading Services by rwbt on Tuesday December 04, 2012 @02:07PM (#4872652)
I would prefer email service from a dedicated email provider rather than a domain provider. Can you imagine relying on someone like Godaddy for your email? Granted, Gandi might be much better than GoDaddy, but still not a great idea. You can still have email at your own domain but have them hosted by a different provider. (Like Google Apps).
Re:The Best Replacements for Privacy-Invading Services by sp332 on Tuesday December 04, 2012 @02:37PM (#4872825)
I already have email on my own domain, even though I currently have it pointing to Gmail (for spam filtering and webmail access), I can point it to any server I want in the future since I own the domain.
Re:The Best Replacements for Privacy-Invading Services by JoshTriplett on Tuesday December 04, 2012 @06:06PM (#4873851)
Anyone with the ability to run their own mail server can do this, as can anyone willing to use Google Apps; Gandi has the nice advantage of not having to run your own mail server.

In my case, I use their server for SMTP, and run my own IMAP server, moving mail from theirs to mine as it arrives.

Re:The Best Replacements for Privacy-Invading Services by rsync on Tuesday December 04, 2012 @03:15PM (#4873025)
I'll just leave this here...

http://www.rsync.net/philosophy.html

Re:The Best Replacements for Privacy-Invading Services by selectout on Tuesday December 04, 2012 @02:07PM (#4872653)
Some of these are genuinely good alternatives but the headline is a bit too attention grabbing. A lot of these "privacy-invading" services are free (and offer more for free) than the non "privacy-invading" alternatives. If you aren't paying for it, you are probably the product holds very true.

For most people I have found that getting something a bit better for free is worth giving up on a bit of their privacy. I do believe however that privacy education and providing the details outside of a long ass privacy policy is very key moving forward.

Re:The Best Replacements for Privacy-Invading Services by rwbt on Tuesday December 04, 2012 @01:41PM (#4872479)
I was recently considering switching to Fastmail from Gmail (Privacy, Lack of Support etc.,) but not entirely sure about Fastmail. I've never heard of Lavabit before. I wonder how they stack up against Fastmail in-terms of Privacy, Support, Security and Reliability.

I think Two-factor authentication in Gmail provides a great additional layer of security. Unfortunately, I don't think many other email providers support it.

Re:The Best Replacements for Privacy-Invading Services by Flimm on Tuesday December 04, 2012 @02:21PM (#4872726)
Fastmail does offer two-factor authentication with SMS: https://www.fastmail.fm/help/features_alternative_logins.htm...

You can also set up passwords that are only authorised for read-only access, one hour passwords, one-time passwords and Yubikey logins.

Re:The Best Replacements for Privacy-Invading Services by jfb on Tuesday December 04, 2012 @02:48PM (#4872888)
I am very happy with fastmail. I host my personal email there, and over the last three years, have had significantly fewer connectivity problems than with Google Apps hosted work email. Which is not to say that GApps is unreliable (it clearly isn't) -- just that fastmail works fine.
Re:The Best Replacements for Privacy-Invading Services by ineedtosleep on Tuesday December 04, 2012 @02:15PM (#4872699)
About the 2-factor bit: Fastmail supports Yubikey for 2 factor auth and is available on free accounts.
Re:The Best Replacements for Privacy-Invading Services by tome on Tuesday December 04, 2012 @02:28PM (#4872766)
An alternative to Google Calendar would be nice.
Re:The Best Replacements for Privacy-Invading Services by rdl on Wednesday December 05, 2012 @01:07AM (#4875130)
What's wrong with running your own WebDAV/iCal calendar, using something like Kerio?
Re:The Best Replacements for Privacy-Invading Services by derrida on Tuesday December 04, 2012 @06:09PM (#4873862)
Does anybody know if SpiderOak is open source? This matters because it is claiming to be cryptographically secure.
Re:The Best Replacements for Privacy-Invading Services by lh7777 on Tuesday December 04, 2012 @07:59PM (#4874286)
No. From their Engineering page:

> ...our plan all along has been to make our entire code base open source; however, as anyone who has worked with such issues knows, it is often not quite that simple. We are committed and will continue to work toward an open source environment.

They have some open source bits (see https://spideroak.com/code) and presumably it's built on top of FOSS libraries, but still definitely proprietary.

Re:The Best Replacements for Privacy-Invading Services by danso on Tuesday December 04, 2012 @02:54PM (#4872917)
The idea that you can find a privacy-protecting social service as a substitute for Facebook is just absurd. FB very well, at some point or already, may maliciously intrude on you. But the vast majority of horror stories arise from the kind of behavior of users and their friends that cannot be prevented by any (non draconian) social platform.

In other words, the privacy problems arise from people being social...if you want maximal privacy, then the only solution is minimal sociability. This is the case with online networks as it is at e water cooler. So finding a privacy-protecting platform -- that is, the kind of privacy that most people want -- is like finding a way of gossiping that prevents words from being repeated and secret pacts in breakable.

* an example comes to mind: recently on another FB thread, someone said how FB nearly destroyed his marriage because his fiancé had, as her profile pic, a photo of both of them before the relationship was known to the family. fB is obviously wrong to revert privacy settings, but thhe relationship should never have been broadcasted in any pictorial form, because any "friend" could CC or refer to the photo regardless of FB privacy settings

Re:The Best Replacements for Privacy-Invading Services by mylittlepony on Tuesday December 04, 2012 @04:47PM (#4873448)
How come DuckDuckGo is so famous, and nobody knows about StartPage? https://startpage.com

Check out all the features it has, it's way superior if you ask me.

Re:The Best Replacements for Privacy-Invading Services by lh7777 on Tuesday December 04, 2012 @07:56PM (#4874278)
I've found DuckDuckGo to be slow and very poor at long-tail searches. +1 for StartPage as a credible Google alternative.
Re:The Best Replacements for Privacy-Invading Services by mylittlepony on Tuesday December 04, 2012 @04:53PM (#4873476)
Labavit sounded great, until I read this part:

"To ensure maximum security, passwords are hashed using the Secure Hash Algorithm (SHA). SHA takes the plaintext password as its input and produces a random 512 bit string as the output. With only the SHA output, it is cryptographically impossible to determine the original input. Effectively, hashing is a repeatable one-way process."