And your second will be struggling to clean up that mess while also getting their own work done.
Of course, you expect the same level of work from both of them, but because person two has to do a bunch of person one's work as well as their own, person one ends up looking better and gets praised by management.
I'm totally not bitter at all.
> it's usually better off in the long run to shove the new process down group B's throat.
> (…) the "Group B" employee (…) is more conscientious and reliable than anyone else we've ever hired
If employee B is proving themselves to be valuable and reliable, then you should trust them to make the best decisions for how they’re going to go about their work and support them. Leave the door open for them to try different things, but no one likes having processes shoved down their throats (your words). All you’re doing is making them unhappy and more likely to leave to go work for someone who’ll value them like they deserve.
I run a small business with two employees.
N=2 here, of course, but one of them will experiment with any new process you introduce (as well as plenty more that you don't!)
The other will keep doing what he's always been doing, even if it's frustrating and inefficient, unless you monitor him and force him to use the new process.
I could imagine most "normal employers" would understand that both type of person exists and, assuming you're getting good first impressions from group A, it's usually better off in the long run to shove the new process down group B's throat.