News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Professor denounces mass AI fraud on an exam at Brown Uni... by redwall_hp on Sunday June 28, 2026 @06:51PM (#48712579)
It's news to me that they weren't already. My exams were all in person and on paper in the early 2020s, and even my physics homework was a "do it on engineering paper and drop it in a mail slot" affair. The professors would forbid computers and phones during lectures and would stop to shame anyone who thought they were being sneaky.

Computer Science classes were all on paper for exams, and low level ones did the old "here's a Javadoc, write some code with a pencil."

The only online exams I had were for 100 level electives.

Re:Professor denounces mass AI fraud on an exam at Brown Uni... by markus_zhang on Sunday June 28, 2026 @07:02PM (#48712680)
IMO many CS classes should be lab based already, except the theory heavy ones. I still wonder why MIT needs to test students of OS courses on paper when the labs cover a lot of the ground. If I can do well in the labs I wouldn’t bother to memorize stuffs for the exams.
Re:Professor denounces mass AI fraud on an exam at Brown Uni... by fn-mote on Sunday June 28, 2026 @07:56PM (#48713088)
You have to test to make sure the student who you are giving the grade to is the student who did the work.

Without certifying someone’s abilities, the degree doesn’t mean much.

Re:Professor denounces mass AI fraud on an exam at Brown Uni... by nothercastle on Sunday June 28, 2026 @10:16PM (#48714031)
The degree doesn’t mean much and never did. Minimum bar that’s all
Re:Professor denounces mass AI fraud on an exam at Brown Uni... by kevin_thibedeau on Sunday June 28, 2026 @09:16PM (#48713628)
CS is a science of computation curriculum, not programming. You can have automation do all the work for you in the labs.
Re:Professor denounces mass AI fraud on an exam at Brown Uni... by crazylogger on Monday June 29, 2026 @02:12AM (#48715459)
Students will just one-shot whatever lab problems professor comes up with using Claude Code.
Re:Professor denounces mass AI fraud on an exam at Brown Uni... by bee_rider on Sunday June 28, 2026 @08:04PM (#48713135)
I think “take home open book exam, good luck,” followed by evil laughter, is mostly a math department thing.
Re:Professor denounces mass AI fraud on an exam at Brown Uni... by atty on Sunday June 28, 2026 @08:25PM (#48713269)
And physics
Re:Professor denounces mass AI fraud on an exam at Brown Uni... by analog31 on Sunday June 28, 2026 @09:12PM (#48713610)
Yeah, many of my physics exams were take-home open-book. One that I particularly remember: "Here's your exam. There's one problem. It's due when you come back from spring break."
Re:Professor denounces mass AI fraud on an exam at Brown Uni... by bschwindHN on Sunday June 28, 2026 @09:37PM (#48713780)
I graduated forever ago, but I still have bad dreams about this type of homework. That and the "oh no, I somehow forgot to go to this class all semester and now I have to take the final exam!"
Re:Professor denounces mass AI fraud on an exam at Brown Uni... by annzabelle on Monday June 29, 2026 @12:09AM (#48714685)
I remember having 7 day take home open book open internet exams in my math classes in college. We were also expected to typeset all our answers.

Those exams probably took the median student 30 hours and had a median score of 50% including partial credit.

Sad to think current students will never get that experience, because a chatbot could write something good enough to get a 50% in 10 minutes, for many of those classes.

Re:Professor denounces mass AI fraud on an exam at Brown Uni... by bee_rider on Monday June 29, 2026 @12:58AM (#48714971)
True… but, we’re in a transitional stage still. Eventually, if these models are really going to be such a big deal, then the workflows of real mathematicians will probably involve using them very effectively. Eventually the generation that grew up using the things will become professors, and they’ll be good enough at using the things to ask a question that’s still hard with an LLM.

Well, either that will happen, or the pace of advancement will increase faster than humans can adapt. That’s the singularity, right? I don’t think we’re that close to it.

Re:Professor denounces mass AI fraud on an exam at Brown Uni... by Aurornis on Sunday June 28, 2026 @08:35PM (#48713353)
> It's news to me that they weren't already.

It’s an old (and outdated IMO) tradition at some Ivy Leagues, as the article notes.

It may have worked in the era when students had a little more fear of repercussions and a little more sense that cheating on a test would only cause them problems when courses got harder later.

Now it seems there is little interest in dealing with cheating, as evidenced by how hard it was for this professor to even get attention to the matter within his department. Students also don’t believe cheating will cause them future harm because they assume they can cheat everything up through graduation the same way.

When the rug gets pulled and they have to demonstrate their knowledge in person without ChatGPT, the cheaters collapse. I fear that we’re delaying this reckoning so deep into academic careers now that by the time these students encounter the point where they can’t cheat their way to completion of a course they’re in for a world of hurt, if they continue at all. We really should be coming down hard on cheating earlier and more often.

Re:Professor denounces mass AI fraud on an exam at Brown Uni... by rmunn on Sunday June 28, 2026 @09:37PM (#48713791)
It's an old enough tradition that there are jokes that rely on you knowing the tradition.

My favorite: professor known for being VERY strict tells class repeatedly in weeks leading up to exam, "You will have exactly two hours to finish your exam, and no more. I will not accept exam booklets turned in even one minute past the two hour mark: they will score a zero. Be warned."

Exam day comes, and all but one student are in their seats with the blue exam booklet in front of them when the professor says "Begin." He arches an eyebrow at the empty desk, but says nothing.

Fifteen minutes later, the tardy student rushes in. "Family emergency," he says, "sorry." The professor tells him "You have one hour forty-five minutes." Student says nothing, but opens his book and starts writing furiously.

The two hour mark comes up, and everyone except the tardy student turns in their booklets and leaves the room. The professor reminds him "Time's up," but he just keeps writing in the booklet.

At the 2:12 mark, one hour fifty-seven minutes after he ran into the exam room, the student closes his blue book and walks up to the desk where the other books are stacked up in a messy pile. The professor is reclining in his chair with his feet up on the desk. "Nope," he says, "you're late. I won't accept your exam booklet, and you're going to get a zero on the final exam."

"That's not fair," said the student, "I had to drive my mother to the hospital. I shouldn't be punished for that. I took no more time than anyone else."

"Nope, you knew the rules," says the professor.

"Don't you know who I am?" says the student, raising his voice.

"Nope, don't know, don't care," says the professor.

"Good!" says the student. He slides his exam book into the middle of the messy stack, straightens it up neatly, and before the professor has gotten his feet off the desk, walks briskly out into the hallway.

Re:Professor denounces mass AI fraud on an exam at Brown Uni... by nvlled on Sunday June 28, 2026 @10:22PM (#48714078)
Not to ruin the joke, but he knows and can remember the student's face so I don't think that student can get away with it.
Re:Professor denounces mass AI fraud on an exam at Brown Uni... by rmunn on Sunday June 28, 2026 @10:41PM (#48714186)
I like to think he was amused by the student's audacity and decided that yes, he was being unfair in this particular case. I know not everyone would be so fair-minded, but I like to think that this guy would be.
Re:Professor denounces mass AI fraud on an exam at Brown Uni... by CM30 on Monday June 29, 2026 @07:46AM (#48718012)
Guess it depends how big the university class is. If it's less than 30 students I can see him remembering their face and knowing which person in the list it might be, if there are 50/70/over 100 students enrolled, good luck. It's not like there's a picture of each student's face on the exam booklet or anything.
Re:Professor denounces mass AI fraud on an exam at Brown Uni... by koolba on Sunday June 28, 2026 @09:42PM (#48713820)
Classic story indeed. They gave a version of it in the movie Slackers: https://youtu.be/totdoS6px5k
Re:Professor denounces mass AI fraud on an exam at Brown Uni... by bonoboTP on Sunday June 28, 2026 @09:22PM (#48713680)
> as evidenced by how hard it was for this professor to even get attention to the matter within his department

This is the crux of it. The incentives don't support cracking down on AI cheating much. At least in the short term, for individual department administrators. Overall it will likely hurt the universities collectively to hand out degrees like candy this way, but grade inflation was already a problem and universities treat students like paying customers and they also want good statistics, fend off possible discrimination accusations etc.

So it's really not just about AI, the AI is simply exposing this underlying misaligned incentive. Professors complain about it all the time. It was similar during covid and cheating in online exams and that was solidly before ChatGPT.

Re:Professor denounces mass AI fraud on an exam at Brown Uni... by zahlman on Monday June 29, 2026 @04:22AM (#48716350)
> Students also don’t believe cheating will cause them future harm because they assume they can cheat everything up through graduation the same way.

And in the workplace as well.

And so do their parents.

With alarmingly good reason, at least some of the time.

Re:Professor denounces mass AI fraud on an exam at Brown Uni... by s0rce on Sunday June 28, 2026 @08:43PM (#48713422)
Mine were like this is 2005. The math classes also didn't allow calculators, engineering classes did, but not graphing ones that could store information.
Re:Professor denounces mass AI fraud on an exam at Brown Uni... by consensus1 on Sunday June 28, 2026 @10:10PM (#48713992)
Writing code like that just seems like such a poor test of actual ability. More like just a rote memorization test. On the other hand I can't think of a better way to do it fairly now. I think it speaks to the obsolescence of the educational model more than anything.