News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You are an amazing engineer, but you are a terrible fit f... by btilly on Monday December 03, 2012 @06:12PM (#4868506)
You're assuming sarcasm rather than a "whoa, seriously?" response, which given your social circle is I think fairly unusual isn't accusing you of lying so much as asking if he read it correctly.

I certainly did that.

Of course, assuming bad faith and then using his age as an argument as to why your knee jerk reaction was ok apparently is also an option - but not up to your usual standard. I think perhaps the 'emotional minefield' part is crucial here, and next time you should step away for that hour before replying at all.

In this case stepping away for an hour would not have helped. Because with a strong emotional frame in my head, I had no path from there to seeing any other reaction. It was going to take someone else, in this case you, to show me another possible way to frame it. I'll need to take time to digest that fact before I try to figure out how to avoid responding that way in the future.

Thank you for your helpful response. I'm sorry that I had the reaction that I did. These things happen with humans. Some days more easily than others. Some humans more easily than others.

PS: Ironically, knowing a few successful startup founders is one of the most normal things about my social circle.

Re:You are an amazing engineer, but you are a terrible fit f... by tptacek on Monday December 03, 2012 @07:23PM (#4868792)
Chalk it up to message boards and at least be happy he didn't suggest you sell your kids to fund the company. :)

LATE EDIT WAIT WAIT I CALL THAT BUSINESS MODEL FOR YC'S13

Re:You are an amazing engineer, but you are a terrible fit f... by codewright on Monday December 03, 2012 @07:47PM (#4868886)
I'm making baby back ribs on the BBQ next weekend, so I think I'd be a customer of this company.

I look forward to your application to YC regarding this modest proposal with great interest.

Re:You are an amazing engineer, but you are a terrible fit f... by mst on Monday December 03, 2012 @07:52PM (#4868916)
> Thank you for your helpful response.

You're welcome, that was what I was hoping for.

> I'm sorry that I had the reaction that I did.

Reacted emotionally because of care for your family and then did your best to be more logical about it when given a chance to do so? I'm not sorry, and I'd anticipate their not being sorry either.

(a slightly gratuitous additional reframing perhaps, but one I think deserves to be given voice)