News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You are an amazing engineer, but you are a terrible fit f... by smacktoward on Monday December 03, 2012 @04:02PM (#4867788)
Maybe the problem isn't with the engineers, but with your startup.

Being compensated through equity is a gamble. Most times it doesn't pay off. So many more startups fail than succeed that the odds are heavily stacked against those options ever being worth anything.

Sometimes people are willing to take that gamble anyway, in spite of the horrible odds, because they believe in the business. They look at the product, the founders, and the rest of the team, and think "this is going to be one of the ones that succeeds" -- strongly enough that they're willing to bet their own money (in possibly lost compensation) on the outcome.

If you're showing talented people your idea, or your product, or your team -- or yourself -- and they're not coming away convinced that what you're showing them is good enough to justify taking that risk, maybe it doesn't mean that they're lamers who don't understand startup culture. Maybe it means they looked at what you showed them and decided that it wasn't a horse worth betting on. So they'll work for you for salary, which they can put in the bank the moment you give it to them, but not equity.

If that happens consistently, maybe it's time to step back and look more holistically at your business. If you can't convince potential employees to bet on you, you might have set your product up in such a way that you'll have trouble convincing potential customers to bet on you too.

Re:You are an amazing engineer, but you are a terrible fit f... by kapilkale on Monday December 03, 2012 @04:45PM (#4868044)
Side note, but there are other reasons people will take that gamble.

Sometimes, the reason employees take equity is because they think they will have a nontrivial impact on the business and want to feel like an owner. The actual financial consideration of the equity can be triumphed by the emotional connection it gives them with the team and their work.

This might explain why some early employees don't even know what percent of the company they own.

Re:You are an amazing engineer, but you are a terrible fit f... by aaronbrethorst on Monday December 03, 2012 @05:09PM (#4868188)
1-2% (max!) equity in a company doesn't make me feel like an owner. http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=973106
Re:You are an amazing engineer, but you are a terrible fit f... by moocow01 on Monday December 03, 2012 @06:14PM (#4868521)
Exactly because you really are not.

By the time you get diluted you effectively are a stockholder with way too much of your net worth locked into one likely extremely volatile company. If you are lucky enough to be in a succesful startup you still have to survive the inevitable whiplash when your liquidity frees up.

Ironically and sadly I have a couple old-timer friends who have been through IPOs where they have lost money on the whole damn thing mostly due to taxes and poor timing.

Re:You are an amazing engineer, but you are a terrible fit f... by aaronbrethorst on Monday December 03, 2012 @06:40PM (#4868618)
Treating employee-level equity as anything other than the chance for a nice bonus some day is a sucker's game. Especially for early employees who'll take a significant haircut on salary for the privilege of getting "points on the package" (to quote The Wire)

Edit: and that really sucks for your friends. I feel bad for them :(

Re:You are an amazing engineer, but you are a terrible fit f... by vacri on Monday December 03, 2012 @04:44PM (#4868039)
They did offer salary:

He ... took the two offers we gave them (big salary/small equity and small salary/big equity) and created a custom big salary / big equity + bonus counter offer that was laughable at best.

Re:You are an amazing engineer, but you are a terrible fit f... by robryan on Monday December 03, 2012 @06:29PM (#4868580)
They didn't give a figure though, the salary offer might have still been below what the guy considered his market value so he countered by wanting to bump up the equity to go with it.
Re:You are an amazing engineer, but you are a terrible fit f... by rburhum on Monday December 03, 2012 @04:22PM (#4867920)
I 100% agree with you. And by the way, we did ended up getting great engineers.
Re:You are an amazing engineer, but you are a terrible fit f... by rhizome on Monday December 03, 2012 @05:47PM (#4868405)
Did you wind up hiring a different number of engineers than you were considering when interviewing the guy in the post?