News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bit Traffic: Who Pays for Internet Traffic and Why? by npsimons on Monday December 03, 2012 @02:07PM (#4867205)
The issue is, and this going to be a huge tug of war for a long time to come, is the role of ISPs; either as 'content providers' or as merely a utility provider. One provides huge profits, one is a low margin business.

Well then the answer is clear, the market has spoken: they are utilities. That's how they were setup, that's the bargain they made with We the People, and quite frankly, they don't offer content anyone wants (they aren't Netflix).

"Ooh, I want pay per view and Mediacom/Cox/Comcast digital movies", said no one ever. If they want to provide content, they should not be allowed to anti-competitively discriminate against other content providers. This is exactly what Network Neutrality is about.

Re:Bit Traffic: Who Pays for Internet Traffic and Why? by josh2600 on Monday December 03, 2012 @02:30PM (#4867320)
But how do you force a publicly traded company to become a utility when it's in their best interests not to?
Re:Bit Traffic: Who Pays for Internet Traffic and Why? by xyzzy123 on Tuesday December 04, 2012 @04:23AM (#4870127)
The stick is regulation, and the carrot is money.

Unfortunately, it's really hard to do once the govt. money is spent. I'm familiar with AU/NZ. Both are pumping significant public money into broadband infrastructure, and they took different approaches to enforcing fair network access.

In AU, they created a new company (NBN co) to run the "utility" part. See: http://whirlpool.net.au/wiki/nbn

The government is paying the monopoly incumbent to switch users onto the new network.

In NZ, our privately owned largest telco (Telecom NZ) semi-voluntarily split itself into two parts - a retail and a wholesale branch. The shareholders agreed to do this, because that meant the wholesale part (Chorus) would get a big govt. contract to lay fiber to the door.

In theory, the split is "arms length", so other network providers can access the infrastructure on fair terms.

Reference: http://www.stuff.co.nz/business/industries/5858284/Telecom-s...

It remains to be seen whether this is the right way to go about things, but both approaches do seem plausible.