News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Unbearable Cheapness of Open Weight Models by NitpickLawyer on Thursday June 25, 2026 @04:21AM (#48670531)
> will put data centers in orbit. A pipe dream.

Cheap access to space was once a pipe dream.

Reusable boosters were once a pipe dream.

A new player beating Boeing to the ISS was once a pipe dream.

LEO constellations were once a pipe dream.

Launching thousands of satellites was once a pipe dream.

You should know that a) they are already running "AI" chips on their current sats. and b) they are already producing kW of power on orbit and have ~10k sats on orbit. You can watch Scott Manley's video on it, where he does some rough calculations and explains the overall architecture. There is nothing stopping them to do this, from an engineering perspective. If it makes commercial sense, that's another question, but 5-10-20 years in the future things might change there as well.

Re:The Unbearable Cheapness of Open Weight Models by ben_w on Thursday June 25, 2026 @07:07AM (#48671734)
> You can watch Scott Manley's video on it, where he does some rough calculations and explains the overall architecture.

I'm currently writing a blog post, and there's one big thing everyone, including Scott Manley, missed.

Once I realised it, I wondered what took me so long to spot this issue.

Re:The Unbearable Cheapness of Open Weight Models by jgord on Thursday June 25, 2026 @05:14PM (#48679299)
care to share the one glaring obstacle ?

slightly related .. I saw a talk on DCs in space, and it said median Earth orbit had a latency of 500ms .. but back of envelope seems to be : 15,000km above Earth would have around 100ms latency, comparable to internet ping times.

Not an expert, feel free to weigh in.

Re:The Unbearable Cheapness of Open Weight Models by ben_w on Friday June 26, 2026 @05:17AM (#48684314)
> care to share the one glaring obstacle ?

I'm still working on the blog, but as a quickie: it's the lesson of the Datasaurus dozen, that sometimes you need to look at the actual distribution rather than statistics.

Here's what the safety exclusion zone around a million of them in orbit looks like, if arranged something like the current plan: https://raw.githubusercontent.com/BenWheatley/blog/refs/head...

There's no (safe) gaps. Plenty of physical space, but the safety margin eats it all up. Nothing else is allowed to use those orbital shells or anything between them.

Also, this is what happens if you put them all in a single orbit at the same altitude:

https://raw.githubusercontent.com/BenWheatley/blog/refs/head...

> slightly related .. I saw a talk on DCs in space, and it said median Earth orbit had a latency of 500ms .. but back of envelope seems to be : 15,000km above Earth would have around 100ms latency, comparable to internet ping times.

500ms means ~150,000 km travel distance; for that distance as round-trip time from origin to destination and back again means the one-way distance is 75,000 km, so if it's via a single satellite bounce then the average distance to the satellite would be 37,500 km: [You]-37.5Mm-[Satellite]-37.5Mm-[Them]-37.5Mm-[Satellite]-37.5Mm-[You].

I think they must be assuming all comms are via geostationary satellites. In some talks, this is what the speaker actually meant, though they may not have been clear about it; other times, there's talks from people who copied the former but perhaps didn't understand.

For DCs in space, even in GEO, it would be half the distance because you're communicating with the satellite itself not with someone else somewhere else on the ground.

Re:The Unbearable Cheapness of Open Weight Models by amanaplanacanal on Friday June 26, 2026 @06:29AM (#48684887)
My gut says another obstacle is maintenance. How long can a datacenter on the ground run without maintenance? How will this be affordable in orbit?
Re:The Unbearable Cheapness of Open Weight Models by ben_w on Friday June 26, 2026 @06:58AM (#48685129)
People already talk about that, so I wouldn't be adding much new. That said, had already put in a bit about cost of launching.

TL;DR: Alphabet researchers (and Alphabet owns more of SpaceX than the entire IPO so if anything they're biased to optimism), recon it will take SpaceX launching about 370,000 tons to orbit before they've even figured out how to get the costs down to the point it makes sense to put these in orbit.

Re:The Unbearable Cheapness of Open Weight Models by InsideOutSanta on Thursday June 25, 2026 @04:44AM (#48670698)
I don't think people's argument is that it's impossible to put data centers into space. The argument is that the downsides (radiation, cooling, maintenance, power) are so severe that it is pointless to do it at scale.
Re:The Unbearable Cheapness of Open Weight Models by NitpickLawyer on Thursday June 25, 2026 @04:55AM (#48670820)
Go back to the megathreads when this came up. Even here on HN. Plenty of people used the argument that it can't be done, for various reasons.

And my point was that at one point or the other there were many "downsides" for all the tech that SpaceX already has. Reusable boosters were seen as "uneconomical" and "pointless unless they can fly 10 times" by industry experts. They're now flying 30+times a booster.

LEO constellations were similarly "full of downsides" plus "all the companies that tried it went bankrupt in the 90s", so "it's pointless". And so on.

Re:The Unbearable Cheapness of Open Weight Models by InsideOutSanta on Thursday June 25, 2026 @05:33AM (#48671099)
Reusable boosters have clear upsides, though.

Pretty much everything about data centers in space is worse than having them on Earth. Apart from niche use cases, the only reason you'd talk about data centers in space is if you had a company with rocket ships and needed a story to tie your rocket ships to the current AI craze.

Re:The Unbearable Cheapness of Open Weight Models by grebc on Thursday June 25, 2026 @07:29AM (#48671890)
And you had a lot of stock to sell to bagholders.
Re:The Unbearable Cheapness of Open Weight Models by dogwalker5000 on Thursday June 25, 2026 @06:27AM (#48671453)
Yet spacex is losing money … only StarLink is profitable.
Re:The Unbearable Cheapness of Open Weight Models by jujube3 on Saturday June 27, 2026 @03:32PM (#48701011)
These guys aren't aware of all the "impossible" problems Elon already solved. They're too invested in the propaganda about him being a big dumb idiot who accidentally fell backwards into a pile of 1 trillion dollars.
Re:The Unbearable Cheapness of Open Weight Models by general1465 on Thursday June 25, 2026 @05:07AM (#48670911)
Microsoft tried to put datacenters into ocean [1] and then shelved the idea, because even that you have lower amount of failures, you still have failures and somebody has to go there and fix them. Which turns out to be problem.

And in ocean you don't have to solve for radiation nor cooling.

[1] https://www.tomshardware.com/desktops/servers/microsoft-shel...

Re:The Unbearable Cheapness of Open Weight Models by IncreasePosts on Thursday June 25, 2026 @04:46AM (#48670727)
If just Elon was taking about data centers in space, you could take it with a grain of salt. But there are other serious players talking about it like Google and blue origin that it should be pretty clear it can't just be dismissed with "you didn't think about cooling!"
Re:The Unbearable Cheapness of Open Weight Models by NitpickLawyer on Thursday June 25, 2026 @04:52AM (#48670786)
Yeah, and there's already been tech demonstrators for this. Starcloud-1 launched in '25 (on a F9) and demoed a CotS H100 in a ~60kg bus w/ 1kW of power. They ran inference on a "gemini" model (probably something small) and trained a GPT2 version LLM as a tech demonstrator.
Re:The Unbearable Cheapness of Open Weight Models by ForHackernews on Thursday June 25, 2026 @05:06AM (#48670904)
Google also wanted to deliver internet from balloons and put everyone's real name on their YouTube comments. Not all their ideas are winners.
Re:The Unbearable Cheapness of Open Weight Models by hyhatqtv on Saturday June 27, 2026 @06:06AM (#48696849)
Sure, you can do it. I bet humans could fly to Mars if we invested a massive amount of resources into it. Why, though? That’s the “easy” if you throw sufficient amounts of money at problems over sufficient periods of time you can solve them.

If you don’t care about making any more from it. How exactly would datacenters in space would be more profitable than those on earth?