If that were true...
the software industry would be in REAL trouble.
I also had an issue with a 1Gen time capsule, which when it broke got replaced in store no questions asked.
I guess I have been lucky?
Issues can appear, especially with first gen products. I can totally understand that. I cannot for the life of me understand how Apple decided to handle this issue. I’m just not used to Apple treating their customers with contempt and treating them like stupid idiots.
The point isn't with the fact that there is an issue, its that Apple is seemingly trying to sweep it under the rug.
> The point isn't with the fact that there is an issue, its that Apple is seemingly trying to sweep it under the rug.
I think you missed the whole point of OP post: That is exactly what Apple has a reputation for doing. For example: The Antenna Fiasco -
http://www.engadget.com/2010/06/24/apple-responds-over-iphon...
I don't think that's quite it. Apple realises there's a problem, and that's why they have the standardised test. I think the real problem here is that Apple's test is insufficient, but they don't know that, so they don't believe their customers when they say they're having still having issues. And that's not reassuring for someone who's just spent a lot of money on a new machine.
Personally, I've never had this issue with my rMBP, but I'm sympathetic with those that do.
I personally can't see how they could not know, this is not the kind of issue where ppl are going to be blowing there whistle for no reason. So Apple knows there is an issue, if there own tests do not match the numbers of complains(to some degree) even more red flags should be going up.
I am no conspiracy theorist, but there seems to be some valid points in the article.
>I remember an Apple that bent over backwards to understand its customers’ point of view and stretched itself to meet the high expectations it sets.
Apple has always bent over to resolve issues for customers if they acknowledge the issue. For example, I had a pre-unibody MBP that the power button pushed through the top case. Apple very promptly took it back, replaced the top case and a few other cosmetic dings I hadn't complained about, and got it back to me.
On the other hand, Apple also has a long history of refusing to acknowledge some issues and giving the customer the run around on them, which is the type of complaint in this article.
I never had an issue, and despite everyone at my office having iPhone4s and 4Ss, the only time any of us were ever able to affect antenna-strength was having a wet hand, and then purposefully applying a lot of pressure to attempt to attenuate the case.
It could be the signal-strength display "fix" was hiding issues (actually, this is almost certainly the case), but in practice, it was never an issue, and the 4 had consistently better signal than any other device I've owned, including a GalaxyS2 since the iPhones could get a good enough signal in elevators that previous phones (both iPhone and Android) didn't.
And despite being the same basic design AFAICT, never seen a mention of the issue with the iPhone5.
The iPhone 4S and 5 has a different antenna design and (i think) has some kind of coating on the metal frame to lessen the issue.
Person A: Apple is amazing. Antenna-gate was mass media nonsense.
Person B: I, personally, had major problems with the antenna.
Person C: Why don't you just get rid of your phone then? No one told you to buy one.
Or, I can demand the quality and service I expect from a premium product. What's wrong with that?
One issue doesn't mean you have to hate the phone as a whole, or stop using it. The more acceptable response is to ask that the issue be fixed. Just because an iPhone has signal issues that are inconvenient doesn't mean it's not the phone that this person likes better than the others.
The point is, the iPhone is what these customers were looking for. They still like it enough to keep it, and they like it enough to complain when there are quality issues rather than switch.
What possible other response from a customer service perspective could you want here?
Second gen Macbook Air's had Logic board issues, 2007 era RevA Macbook Pros had video card issues, dodgy graphics cards on the early Mac Pros, the iPhone4 antenna, the list is endless. Often it's taken years for the issues to be resolved and Apple to pay for repairs, if at all.
It's simple, if you want the shiniest tech, buy whatever Apple is selling today. If you want reliable hardware, wait for the first revision when the kinks have been worked out. That way we don't all get spammed with the histronics of endless bloggers who think this is a new phenomenon.