Re:MSc Thesis – The Limits of Generalized Sync
by andersmurphy on Wednesday June 24, 2026 @02:25AM
(#48655934)
Yeah, it's an intellectually intoxicating idea but incredibly hard to get right.
For me the problem is that in practice it only fits really well with quite a specific subset of problems, but we desperately want it to be a general solution that can apply to all the things (or at least it's often marketed that way).
In his MSc thesis, my student Mikael Siidorow looked into the space to find out the limits of generalized sync. He did his study through multiple methods including literature review, interviews, and a case study. In the end he came up with a taxonomy showing where generalized sync breaks and what you have to keep in mind when implementing these solutions.
This is not to say sync engines are useless, but that there are clear tradeoffs to consider when introducing them to your codebase especially if you have to deal with an offline requirement.