Re:Spying on kids to save kids from spying is stupid
by actionfromafar on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @10:44AM
(#48645817)
Could we instead disallow algorithmic skinner-box addiction machines for everyone?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Spying on kids to save kids from spying is stupid
by inigyou on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @11:06AM
(#48646194)
How can you tell what one is? Reddit in 2010? Facebook in 2005? IRC in 1999?
Re:Spying on kids to save kids from spying is stupid
by amanaplanacanal on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @11:17AM
(#48646411)
If the users chooses what they are shown and the order they are shown in, then it's fine. If the platform chooses, then it's not, because they will always choose what creates the most engagement.
Re:Spying on kids to save kids from spying is stupid
by inigyou on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @11:22AM
(#48646507)
So HN should be banned
Re:Spying on kids to save kids from spying is stupid
by amanaplanacanal on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @11:25AM
(#48646551)
Not necessarily. Just fix the algorithm. Showing all submissions by time should be ok, showing all submissions by number of upvotes should be ok if the user chooses that.
Re:Spying on kids to save kids from spying is stupid
by inigyou on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @12:08PM
(#48647203)
The platform can also add ghost upvotes and downvotes and censor upvotes and downvotes.
Re:Spying on kids to save kids from spying is stupid
by actionfromafar on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @04:49PM
(#48651188)
That could be penalized, ultimately by breaking up the company and selling it in parts.
Re:Spying on kids to save kids from spying is stupid
by inigyou on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @11:55PM
(#48654894)
Well, yeah, it could be. Is that your proposal?
Re:Spying on kids to save kids from spying is stupid
by micromacrofoot on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @11:33AM
(#48646689)
That's the problem, recommendation algorithms on networks beyond a certain scale should be publicly auditable.
If they're not, I should be able to opt-out of them.
Re:Spying on kids to save kids from spying is stupid
by actionfromafar on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @11:12AM
(#48646301)
I think I would be fine with a positive enumeration. Some ideas for serving content:
- purely random
- sponsored but without user tracking (like old school TV ads)
- sponsored for user selected geographical area feed
- sponsored for user current location geographical area feed
- follow "friends" or influencers
- purely timeline
- discussion boards
- timeline (IRC like)
- threaded
- user votes (not magic platform votes)
- follow keywords
Re:Spying on kids to save kids from spying is stupid
by inigyou on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @11:13AM
(#48646336)
So Hacker News wouldn't be allowed?
Re:Spying on kids to save kids from spying is stupid
by actionfromafar on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @11:20AM
(#48646462)
I think it should be, maybe I'm missing some aspect, I just cooked up a simple list of rules on the spot, sheesh :-D
Edit: huh, I'm probably stupid, but can you explain more?
Re:Spying on kids to save kids from spying is stupid
by inigyou on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @11:22AM
(#48646510)
HN uses magical platform votes.
Re:Spying on kids to save kids from spying is stupid
by rootusrootus on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @01:00PM
(#48647903)
And it should be transparent about it. When Dan uses a magic lever, it should be visible.
Re:Spying on kids to save kids from spying is stupid
by inigyou on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @02:07PM
(#48648896)
Would Facebook be okay if all the Nazi propaganda posts were tagged "Facebook boosted this post"?
Re:Spying on kids to save kids from spying is stupid
by actionfromafar on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @04:50PM
(#48651198)
If they did boost it, why shouldn't they tell us?
Re:Spying on kids to save kids from spying is stupid
by inigyou on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @11:55PM
(#48654898)
Would that be all that's required to make it okay?
Re:Spying on kids to save kids from spying is stupid
by actionfromafar on Wednesday June 24, 2026 @08:59AM
(#48659061)
No, I don't think so.
Re:Spying on kids to save kids from spying is stupid
by infinitezest on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @12:41PM
(#48647648)
Is heroin the same as beer? Who even knows.
Re:Spying on kids to save kids from spying is stupid
by gampleman on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @10:50AM
(#48645918)
I think this is really the only serious alternative.
Re:Spying on kids to save kids from spying is stupid
by anmalkov on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @10:56AM
(#48646015)
Exactly. Fix the addiction machine, not just who gets checked at the door.
Re:Spying on kids to save kids from spying is stupid
by jonathanstrange on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @10:53AM
(#48645965)
How about taking some personal responsibility for your life?
This shouldn't even be a consideration concerning adults.
Re:Spying on kids to save kids from spying is stupid
by macintux on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @11:06AM
(#48646188)
It's clear by now that the societal impact is significant. I can banish all the social networks from my life and they'll still be corrupting the political process, promoting divisive content, etc.
Re:Spying on kids to save kids from spying is stupid
by actionfromafar on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @11:06AM
(#48646203)
I assume you are also for heroin vending machines at every school corner if you watch a 30 second ad slot. You don't have to use them, you know.
Re:Spying on kids to save kids from spying is stupid
by jMyles on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @11:42AM
(#48646841)
Your extreme example of a policy regarding distribution of heroin is far from perfect, but also far better than prohibition, which has visited upon the world more death, disease, crime, and cartel enrichment than perhaps any other policy in history.
But surely we can do better than either of these extremes.
Re:Spying on kids to save kids from spying is stupid
by jonathanstrange on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @12:46PM
(#48647713)
No, but I'm not against selling alcohol and fast sports cars to adults, for example. I'm not very fond of a nanny state that prohibits almost everything to adults "for their sake" and because the government knows so much better.
Re:Spying on kids to save kids from spying is stupid
by rootusrootus on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @01:29PM
(#48648344)
It is somewhat more challenging for the vendor selling alcohol or sports cars to manipulate your thinking, so the analogy is strained.
Re:Spying on kids to save kids from spying is stupid
by jonathanstrange on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @01:37PM
(#48648457)
[citation needed]
Re:Spying on kids to save kids from spying is stupid
by rootusrootus on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @01:27PM
(#48648322)
> This shouldn't even be a consideration concerning adults.
Ban the boxes for kids
Re:Spying on kids to save kids from spying is stupid
by jonathanstrange on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @01:39PM
(#48648481)
I was replying specifically to someone who insinuated that all social media (or, at least, all supposedly addictive social media) should be banned for everyone, including adults. To me, it's a matter of personal freedom that they shouldn't be banned for adults.