Re:HPV jabs cut risk of dying from cervical cancer before 30...
by pfdietz on Tuesday June 23, 2026 @06:35AM
(#48642898)
> The average female life expectancy is 81.
This is a quibble that does not substantially alter the conclusion.
> And the shots only matter during the window of your life where cervical cancer is remotely relevant, which is during a typical sexual window where somebody may have multiple partners.
Already taken into account in your "save 1 week" conclusion. No double counting please.
> And this is again before we even get into real efficacy, side effects, and other issues which matter quite a lot
This argues in favor of the shots, as I have been ignoring the real cost of cancers to those who don't die of them, or who suffer before they die.
> And more generally, I think converting this issue into weeks starts to emphasize how broken a metric statistical value of life is.
You're calling it broken because it's showing you're wrong.
Something like the statistical value of a life is necessary because tradeoffs between different options must be made. If those tradeoffs are made consistently, a value of life naturally falls out.
This is a quibble that does not substantially alter the conclusion.
> And the shots only matter during the window of your life where cervical cancer is remotely relevant, which is during a typical sexual window where somebody may have multiple partners.
Already taken into account in your "save 1 week" conclusion. No double counting please.
> And this is again before we even get into real efficacy, side effects, and other issues which matter quite a lot
This argues in favor of the shots, as I have been ignoring the real cost of cancers to those who don't die of them, or who suffer before they die.
> And more generally, I think converting this issue into weeks starts to emphasize how broken a metric statistical value of life is.
You're calling it broken because it's showing you're wrong.
Something like the statistical value of a life is necessary because tradeoffs between different options must be made. If those tradeoffs are made consistently, a value of life naturally falls out.