Re:Rent collections are down in New York
by wahern on Monday June 22, 2026 @10:49AM
(#48630976)
> affordable state-owned housing
FWIW, 90% of Singaporeans are homeowners. 80% of housing was publicly built, but it's built to be sold to citizens and residents through various programs that subsidize the first-sale price. Selling is hugely important because it frees up capital for new projects, ownership has many social benefits, and the downsides of ownership are mitigated by Singapore's hybrid model. Advocates for mass-scale publicly built affordable rental projects in cities like SF have clearly never done the napkin math. It's simply not feasible to build housing at scale without leveraging private capital markets.
Singapore does own most land; development projects are typically given long (e.g. 99 year) leaseholds, as opposed to freeholds common in the US. But this is typical in Malaysia and some other countries, as well. What matters is how leasehold extensions are managed in practice. Assuming leaseholds aren't extended as a matter of course for far below market prices, homes on leasehold land tend not to appreciate, or even depreciate, during the final decades. That creates low-cost opportunities for people prepared to deal, or not deal, with the renewal process, for example someone entering their final years and wanting to downsize.
In the US there are examples of housing development on leasehold land, including on publicly owned land. Such condos are typically substantially cheaper, but it's rare and not done systematically. Part of the reason is the mortgage market in the US isn't used to that kind of arrangement, so financing can be difficult, including finding a bank willing to do it. In cities like SF it's much easier these days, though, because the insane housing market has spurred demand for less familiar mortgage products.
FWIW, 90% of Singaporeans are homeowners. 80% of housing was publicly built, but it's built to be sold to citizens and residents through various programs that subsidize the first-sale price. Selling is hugely important because it frees up capital for new projects, ownership has many social benefits, and the downsides of ownership are mitigated by Singapore's hybrid model. Advocates for mass-scale publicly built affordable rental projects in cities like SF have clearly never done the napkin math. It's simply not feasible to build housing at scale without leveraging private capital markets.
Singapore does own most land; development projects are typically given long (e.g. 99 year) leaseholds, as opposed to freeholds common in the US. But this is typical in Malaysia and some other countries, as well. What matters is how leasehold extensions are managed in practice. Assuming leaseholds aren't extended as a matter of course for far below market prices, homes on leasehold land tend not to appreciate, or even depreciate, during the final decades. That creates low-cost opportunities for people prepared to deal, or not deal, with the renewal process, for example someone entering their final years and wanting to downsize.
In the US there are examples of housing development on leasehold land, including on publicly owned land. Such condos are typically substantially cheaper, but it's rare and not done systematically. Part of the reason is the mortgage market in the US isn't used to that kind of arrangement, so financing can be difficult, including finding a bank willing to do it. In cities like SF it's much easier these days, though, because the insane housing market has spurred demand for less familiar mortgage products.