News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Court Records Should Be Free by AnthonyMouse on Saturday June 20, 2026 @04:11AM (#48607322)
> But the thing here is: there's no free money. We all pay for the service line replacement one way or the other

Which is a major difference between that and PACER, since they're serving text and the marginal cost of more people having access to it is essentially zero.

If you make the homeowners pay for the service line replacement, the number of service lines that will be replaced is the same. If you make the public pay for access to the law, this happens:

> Overwhelmingly, PACER is used by attorneys, who are generally well-compensated professionals with a whole host of protectionist policies insulating them from market forces.

...because everyone else is priced out by the fees, or even just the friction of having to configure payments for someone who is only going to use it once. Which means the general public loses out on having access to something it would have a negligible marginal cost to give them.

Imagine, for example, an open source project to search or otherwise process court opinions, which then needs access to all of them. If the government is charging per page, that's completely infeasible. If there is a public torrent of all the opinions, people get to do interesting things they currently can't. And this is not just public information but legal precedent that everyone is expected to comply with -- and yet is being charged to even read it.

There are no comments on this comment yet.