News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Magenta is a color by nostrademons on Wednesday February 18, 2009 @12:50PM (#486008)
This reminds me of my philosophy class, where I learned that it is a significant open question on what color is.
Re:Magenta is a color by soldarnal on Wednesday February 18, 2009 @01:54PM (#486112)
Agreed. A statement like "The truth is, no color actually exists outside of our brain's perception of it." flies in the face of the materialism that is so popular these days. It sounds, rather, a great deal like George Berkeley's idealism: Esse est percipi.
Re:Magenta is a color by apag on Wednesday February 18, 2009 @06:09PM (#486387)
Exactly how would it do that, pray tell?

There is zero contradiction between that statement and materialism.

Re:Magenta is a color by JacobAldridge on Thursday February 19, 2009 @03:48AM (#487014)
I've often wondered "How would you describe colour to a blind person" (obviously, someone who's been blind from birth).

The best I've come up with is comparing it to sound - sharp and dull sounds relate to wavelength, as does colour; loud and soft sounds relate to brightness.

Any better ideas out there? I admit it's a largely pointless exercise, one of many I have to amuse myself.

Re:Magenta is a color by chime on Wednesday February 18, 2009 @05:14PM (#486328)
This brings back memories of green or blue = grue.
Re:Magenta is a color by gjm11 on Thursday February 19, 2009 @07:16AM (#487164)
The usual meaning ("usual"?! Well...) of "grue" is cleverer than that. Or sillier. Or both. Something is "grue" if it's green before (say) midnight at the start of January 1, 2010, and blue after that. You've observed an object many times and it's looked green. It isn't 2010 yet, so you would equally say that it's looked grue. So how come everyone agrees that it's sensible to say "it's green" and expect it to look green in 2010, but not to say "it's grue" and expect it to look blue in 2010? It turns out that lots of simple easy natural answers to this don't stand up well to philosophical nitpicking, and giving a really convincing answer is tricky. Which may or may not tell us something about what it is we're doing when we make generalizations from what we see.

This, of course, is why philosophers get paid the big bucks.

(What about something that looks blue first, and then green? "Bleen", of course. Hence one person's email signature: "It is very dark and after 2000. If you continue, you are likely to be eaten by a bleen." Nelson Goodman's original paper used 2000 rather than 2010 as the cutoff date.)