News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How the Crash Will Reshape America by gaius on Wednesday February 18, 2009 @06:35AM (#485625)
Renting from whom?

Unless you're proposing the government operates a People's Barracks, then housing must be able to make a return for someone or there won't be any liquidity. Which will mean that renters will be just as immobile; they'll have no way to rent a new place at their destination.

Re:How the Crash Will Reshape America by arebop on Wednesday February 18, 2009 @08:02AM (#485676)
Renting could decouple "home" from "house," allowing everyone to behave more rationally and giving the middle class better real estate portfolio diversification.

This doesn't require a People's Barracks. It could be done privately, merely by introducing a layer of indirection between individuals and housing stock.

I see a few problems with this idea. First, given the opportunity to behave more rationally, will most people act on it? Second, it doesn't fully decouple "home" from a physical place. It doesn't address the social environment of family and friends, or the costs of moving one's belongings. My other worry is acknowledged in the article but sort of dismissed: "homeownership has some social benefits—a higher level of civic engagement is one."

Re:How the Crash Will Reshape America by gaius on Wednesday February 18, 2009 @09:52AM (#485794)
Rational behaviour is, in a way, the problem. When New Labour came to power in the UK in the late 1990s, Gordon Brown launched a raid on the pension funds to fuel his extravagant spending plans. Workers in the UK then identified a need for an alternative asset class to save for retirement, as the previously sacrosanct pensions were now seen by the government as a cash cow. Property was the preferred option, and everyone piled into that market.

But what were people supposed to do differently?

Re:How the Crash Will Reshape America by Spyckie on Wednesday February 18, 2009 @08:50AM (#485722)
Well, right now if you want to move quickly and often, the hassle of moving in and out often makes it not worth it to mobilize, and hence you choose not to take a job that is somewhere else but utilizes your skills more effectively (allows you to produce more output in economic terms).

Don't know if a good solution exists... housing is a very messy optimization process because people want vastly different things in their homes. I guess you could focus on niche groups so you can get some standardization going.