Re:GNU Guile 2.0.7 released
by tadfisher on Friday November 30, 2012 @04:34PM
(#4855578)
You might have more experience in this area than I, but is this not the point of the JVM?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
By targeting the JVM, you are giving up on a native user experience. Makes perfect sense when the user interface of your software is programmatic; insanity when you're trying to make software to be used by humans. Clojure is a good lisp, but hardly reason enough to toss all UI convention for. C + Guile makes about a zillion times more sense.
I disagree; you are not tied to Swing or any Java UI toolkit merely by using Clojure on the JVM. You can just as easily integrate with a GTK, Cocoa, and whatever Windows uses.
You'll notice how the current Emacs is weird on all three platforms by default (at least they switched the scrollbar position). C/Guile isn't a panacea for a UI frontend, they're entirely orthogonal.