Re:Paul Graham Is Strawmanning the Left's Argument Against B...
by regularization on Tuesday June 16, 2026 @01:15PM
(#48558561)
> the baby which merely inherited the money
How many babies inherit money? The earliest heirs usually get access to their inheritance is when they choose to at eighteen.
Re:Paul Graham Is Strawmanning the Left's Argument Against B...
by coldtea on Tuesday June 16, 2026 @02:54PM
(#48560186)
That's a pedantic distinction that doesn't matter for the purposes of the argument.
"Baby which inherited the money" could just be baby born into wealth, or baby who will eventually inherit billions when it grows older and its parents die, or baby whose diseased mogul parent left a trust of billions for, or whatever....
This is not a "motte-and-bailey", as the fact that you can't "deserve that billion dollars" is already part of the original "pair of arguments". In a true motte-and-bailey the second argument is implied, here both are given out straight.
Also, “all billionaires are cheaters” trivially doesn't include the baby which merely inherited the money as having actively cheated. It does however trivially include the parent who amassed the amount as a cheater. And thus, it makes inheriting the amount inheriting the fruits of cheating.