I directly tackle the concerns you mentioned, and as a followup I'm actually working on formally verifying the library as well (I've had some success and will publish an update regarding this).
J/K, but seriously, some members of the Rust community might not be happy about your writings.
https://old.reddit.com/r/rust/comments/1tuvxej/iddqd_or_the_...
Marketing of Rust is held very, very dear to some of the people in the community.
imo one of those soundness holes is caused directly from trying to prevent UB - integer overflows. It is inconsistent in Rust what happens in that scenario depending on compiler flags, which basically just makes it UB for any given piece of code. And, unfortunately, default release mode behavior is unsafe.
It lets Rust claim to be UB free without delivering the actual value of being UB free. You still can't rely on a given behavior because it doesn't have one behavior, it has two, and the two behaviors are wildly incompatible with each other.
It is extremely meaningfully different, because the range of options of what can happen is bounded in one case (either two's compliment wrapping, or panic) and unbounded in the other case (literally anything is allowed to happen, including time travel).
This is "implementation defined behavior" in C and C++'s terms, not "undefined behavior."
As a starter / refresher perhaps, both of these are perfectly permissible and happen in practice with UB, but never with "wrap or panic" / "implementation defined" behavior: https://mohitmv.github.io/blog/Shocking-Undefined-Behaviour-... This kind of thing is an example of the "time travel" stevekablanik is referring to, stuff that is literally impossible as written, that absolutely no human would consider to be a reasonable execution of the code, but occurs regularly with UB.
I don't know if Rust will ever attempt to fix this mistake, but I seriously hope they do.
rustc -C overflow-checks=yes
or in your project config, [profile.release]
overflow-checks = true
gives you consistent panics on overflow.In Rust the standard mandates a guaranteed wrap-around or a controlled crash. The default behavior is crashing in debug mode and wrapping-around in release mode, but you can control that with a compiler flag.
No matter how you look at it, the Rust behavior is safer. The default behavior? Way better in Rust than in C++. Want a guaranteed wrap-around? In Rust, check. In C++, depending on the compiler. Want a guaranteed crash? In Rust, check. In C++, depending on the compiler.
Also worth noting that overflowing has much more severe consequences in C++ than in Rust, due to bounds checks.
> I don't know if Rust will ever attempt to fix this mistake
It was discussed many times, and the conclusion is: it is too expensive, and the default will only change if that will change (due to better optimizations and/or better hardware). It is not a mistake, but a conscious decision.
> It was discussed many times, and the conclusion is: it is too expensive, and the default will only change if that will change (due to better optimizations and/or better hardware). It is not a mistake, but a conscious decision.
There's also wrapping_add / saturating_add for anyone concerned about this. Ya want a specific behavior? Just tell the compiler! You can also use the type wrappers so it happens implicitly! https://doc.rust-lang.org/std/num/struct.Saturating.html (presumably this is optimizable on hardware that has operators for this, but idk if that happens yet)
That is exactly why Rust's behavior for +/- operators is a mistake and wrong. It should always panic and anyone that wants something different can specify that in code, where it's clear and explicit.
I have no idea what are you talking about, no_std is just completely irrelevant here.
> Nor if one of the soundness holes in the Rust programming language itself is encountered
Have you actually examined those soundness holes? It is basically impossible to hit them without writing code which is meant to hit them.
And this is also noted in a footnote.
> Nor if there is UB in one of the libraries used as a dependency by the library you are using
If we treat a Rust program globally, this is kinda true. A more true statement will be that UB cannot happen without unsafe code somewhere, including in dependencies (and the original statement can be interpreted as saying that).
But the true power of unsafe is that it's local. If you've reviewed a library and its unsafe is sound, you can ignore it for the rest of the calculation. And of course, the more people review a library the more likely it is that it is sound.
> Which has happened many times, since the Rust standard library is full of unsafe
And here again the post's point stands: many CVEs in std are artificial, you can't exploit them without writing a program that is meant to be exploited. Such thing will never be a CVE in C/C++'s std.
> Rust also requires libraries to be safe regarding unsafe, no matter what kind of insane input that is given to the library and that would otherwise potentially be security issues. Which is too difficult for many library authors.
That is true, that is in fact the post's point: that if they fail this, a CVE will be filled, even if exploitation is just not possible realistically.
But there is a very simple solution for library authors: don't write unsafe code! You don't need to, the vast majority of times. And if you do not have the knowledge (which indeed is more complicated than in C/C++) how to not have an unsound API, then you just should not write unsafe code.
Is 100% relevant.
Did you use ChatGPT to generate your comment?
In broad strokes it's correct, this stuff happens and it's hard to be correct all the time. But are you trying to make a point? Or just ranting?
Also that linked issue was considered a CVE and is fixed (as the article says).
Am I missing something?
Rust also requires libraries to be safe regarding unsafe, no matter what kind of insane input that is given to the library and that would otherwise potentially be security issues. Which is too difficult for many library authors.
And unsafe in Rust is so difficult that many library authors throw their hands up, use Miri, and hope for the best. Even though Miri, all respect to it, has bugs, probability-based testing and other limitations and issues.
UB in both user library and standard library:
https://materialize.com/blog/rust-concurrency-bug-unbounded-...