News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A Tutorial on Anonymous Email Accounts by stinkytaco on Thursday November 29, 2012 @07:19PM (#4851153)
However, deniability becomes less plausible when there's other evidence that makes deniability harder... i.e. Someone claims to have had a conversation with you, the logs of the conversation exists and that person can corroborate that the person on one end was them. Of course you can claim that someone was impersonating you, but what if later you had a recorded phone conversation referencing the OTR conversation, etc.

In and of itself, a piece of evidence is plausibly deniable. In the face or corroborating evidence, it may not be.

Alas, however, I do not have an example from actual case law.

EDIT: I knew I had seen some case law sort of related to this before and it was in re Boucher and US v. Fricosu. They are not directly related to "Plausible Deniability", rather they compelled defendents to decrypt their hard drives. Certainly in the Boucher case there was reason to believe that the contents of the drive were incriminating (the file names were the giveaway, I believe) so perhaps this does not fit in to the exact facts we are trying to recreate, but those are the only two cases that relate that I can recall.

Re:A Tutorial on Anonymous Email Accounts by georgeorwell on Thursday November 29, 2012 @07:34PM (#4851210)
Thanks for elaborating, I better understand the claim that OTR plausible deniability is not that useful in court now.