News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:AI Is Slowing Down by bigstrat2003 on Monday June 08, 2026 @03:51PM (#48450827)
That's the exact opposite of rational. It is, in fact, a formal logical fallacy (ad hominem). His argument can be correct even if he himself is not typically correct.
Re:AI Is Slowing Down by supern0va on Monday June 08, 2026 @04:28PM (#48451440)
On the surface, that's quite fair. However, there's one problem: it is much easier to make statements than to verify them, and that asymmetry is part of why the internet has been slowly eroding society.

It's useful/necessary to use past writing/arguments from an author to say whether they should actually receive any further critical evaluation, or be dismissed. We shouldn't say definitively "they're always wrong, so they're wrong now". However, it's reasonable to say: the author has a demonstrated lack of credibility, so we can probably assume they're wrong here, particularly if they have been wrong in this domain so many times before. Or if they happen to be correct, it's probably not strongly demonstrated by their work.

Re:AI Is Slowing Down by adampunk on Monday June 08, 2026 @08:57PM (#48454750)
What's the point of reading someone's writings on a subject where you know they're not typically correct? How would we know what we 'learn' from Ed is right?