News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bike light that projects the symbol of a bike down onto t... by TeMPOraL on Wednesday November 28, 2012 @10:07AM (#4842840)
> and the flashing mode needs to be between 60 and 240 flashes per minute (which it may do, but doesn't say).

There's a thing I never understood about bike lights - why people use flashing lights? They are distracting like hell, and could probably cause some serious discomfort for people with photosensitive epilepsy.

EDIT:

http://speakingupanyway.wordpress.com/2012/01/07/flashing-li...

Re:Bike light that projects the symbol of a bike down onto t... by jdietrich on Wednesday November 28, 2012 @04:22PM (#4844827)
Flashing lights are much more visible, for a variety of reasons. The most obvious is that you can drive the LED much harder and run the light for longer if it's flashing. Peripheral vision is much more sensitive to flashing lights than solid lights, because we're evolved to be more sensitive to fast-moving objects.

Movement is another key reason for flashing lights - motorists have a great deal of difficulty in accurately judging the speed of cyclists, who are travelling more slowly than them and at a much broader range of speeds. Flashing lights make it much easier to judge speed and distance, which is why the FIA require flashing rear lights to be used on the rear of Formula 1 racing cars in wet weather conditions.

As another commenter stated, bicycle lights flash at the wrong frequency to trigger photosensitive epilepsy.

Re:Bike light that projects the symbol of a bike down onto t... by RobAley on Wednesday November 28, 2012 @10:22AM (#4842926)
My personal feeling is that they are distracting in so far as they cause people to notice the bike, which is intended affect. They are distracting in the same way that emergency services flashing lights are distracting. Personally, at night I use 2 lights, a steady light and a flashing light, and in the day I have a flashing light on (the change in brightness is more noticeable in the daytime than a steady light).

I've seen the epilepsy caused by bike lights thing mentioned a few times, but never by anyone who has directly experienced it (the author of the article you link, and indeed the person she links to, don't appear to have). In the absence of any hard numbers, my intuition is that the number of people suffering from a bike-light-induced-epilepsy incident would be much lower than the number of people suffering a hit-by-car-when-not-using-flashing-light incident, due to the lower number of suffers than cyclists and the requirement to come across a cyclist with light flashing at an appropriate rate, in their direction, with sufficient brightness. I'm happy to be proved wrong of course, and I do have an open mind on that.

Edit: Having read the 8 flashes a second figure mentioned below, and looked it up on other sources online, I no longer have an open mind on the issue!

Edit2: Ok, thats not strictly true, I always have an open mind about everything, but I'll need some hard numbers to pull me the other way...!

Re:Bike light that projects the symbol of a bike down onto t... by alexkus on Wednesday November 28, 2012 @10:20AM (#4842910)
> There's a thing I never understood about bike lights - why people use flashing lights? They are distracting like hell, and could probably cause some serious discomfort for people with photosensitive epilepsy.

They're more visible than a steady light, but it's very hard to gauge closing distance of just a flashing light. For these reasons I use a combination of flashing and steady lights (both front and rear).

As for triggering PSE. They won't. 240 flashes per minute = 4Hz. Perfectly safe.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strobe_light

" Strobe lights and epilepsy ... There have been no known seizures at or below the 8Hz (or 8 flashes per second) level. Most fire alarms in schools, hospitals, stadiums, etc strobe at a 2Hz rate, which is obviously completely safe. "

Re:Bike light that projects the symbol of a bike down onto t... by thisone on Wednesday November 28, 2012 @10:20AM (#4842909)
at night, the flashing gives me even longer warning that I'm coming up on a cyclist, since it's easier to notice a flashing red or white light. A solid light, can be dismissed for a second or two as a reflection.

also, it tells me it's a cyclist and not a small moped.

As a cyclist I like to have a blinking rear light, and two front lights, a blinking one and a steady one. (as a driver, cyclists with a blinker and a steady are the easiest for me to pick out)

Re:Bike light that projects the symbol of a bike down onto t... by ZeroGravitas on Wednesday November 28, 2012 @10:33AM (#4842993)
They use them because they're "distracting", they want to distract you from what you are doing, which is driving over the top of them.

There seem to be some people in the comments of your link disputing this, but the blog author seems to acknowledge it. There also seems to be some confusion around the difference between strobing and flashing lights (depends on the frequency maybe?).

Re:Bike light that projects the symbol of a bike down onto t... by incision on Wednesday November 28, 2012 @10:21AM (#4842918)
>They are distracting like hell

Think about that.