The LLM the person used was trained on a very large corpus of Open Source code, and reproduced that code exactly. Just like LLMs have reproduced chapters of books and articles from the New York Times exactly.
Were those functions trivial? With, say, 1% probability of someone who have not seen them writing them like that?
> Just like LLMs have reproduced chapters of books and articles from the New York Times exactly.
Have you read the articles? As far as I remember they fed large chunks of an article multiple times to an LLM to sometimes get a not-so-long exact match. It can mean that LLMs can infer a style and humans are predictable.
The possibility of SUV clearly shows that a model does more than "just regurgitating."
So they had to prompt? An LLM? I got this argument before and still don’t get what it’s trying to say. These models do not output anything unless prompted, that’s not any kind of gotcha.
On the code outputting front there is a lot of relevant evidence beyond the NYC lawsuit [0].
If I slightly modify GPL code, that doesn’t give me the right to relicense.
[0] https://arxiv.org/html/2601.02671?amp=&= and https://arxiv.org/abs/2506.12286 and https://ai.stanford.edu/blog/verbatim-memorization/
You say you "recognized code". Does it mean that you weren't able to find the exact match?
> an LLM is actually just regurgitating portions of its inputs
You seem to be talking about the inputs to the autoregressive pretraining stage. Correct? Then it's not how LLMs work, unless we use a definition of portions as a "few letters blocks."