> "Claude clearly made things worse" &emdash; the main claim
This article was clearly generated by AI, yet I found no mention/attribution of that by author.
How likely is it than someone who vibe codes articles would also vibe code the underlying analysis and be eager to accept an outcome that is highly validating of that person’s workflow? I’d say very.
> "The scripts used to fetch the data, collate it into a DuckDB database file, construct the views on that DB, and then do the statistical analysis on that data, were indeed written by GLM 5.1, as was the HTML and much of the original prose for the final report webpage you're looking at right now."
So rewritten in his own voice. Maybe the m-dashes are from GLM, maybe from the author.
Also, humans do use em dashes, just FYI.
And the author discussed the use of AI pretty exhaustively in point 0 of the post.
I do critique the conclusion elsewhere in this threat, I personally think the interpretation is misleading and the conclusion is wrong. I will not judge however if the (IMO wrong) conclusion is the author’s own conclusion or if they prompted an AI to reach the conclusion for them.
Data without interpretation is irrelevant, and correct numbers can be interpreted wrongly, either on purpose or by mistake.
I’m not saying any of that happened here, only that “are the numbers wrong” is not the only thing that is relevant.
> humans do use em dashes, just FYI.
Your parent comment is not complaining about em dashes, they are pointing out the article has a literal “&emdash;” in it.
> Here's my favorite part, though. Digging into the data, one of the first things that jumped out at me with blinding clarity was that the worst release, by far, in rsync history was entirely prior to the introduction of Claude ... And yet nobody noticed.
Language really does suggest the article's author does have a dog in this fight and is cloaking opinion in fancy statistics jargon. "Blinding clarity"? All you have to do is draw a plot. And anyway, v3.4.1 was 2025-01-16, technically well within the AI assisted coding era and before attribution was becoming standard practice.