News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Tracing a powerful GNSS interference source over Europe by whizzter on Friday June 05, 2026 @06:50AM (#48410633)
If you start shooting down stuff in orbit, it'll invite retaliation, but even without retaliation there's a huge risk of a Kessler syndrome (especially with all the stuff that SpaceX has put into orbit in recent years).
Re:Tracing a powerful GNSS interference source over Europe by LiamPowell on Friday June 05, 2026 @07:48AM (#48411128)
> especially with all the stuff that SpaceX has put into orbit in recent years

I've heard this repeated a lot but I've never seen anyone do the maths. StarLink satellites are all in very low orbits, so intuitively it seems like most debris from a collision would just end up deorbiting.

Re:Tracing a powerful GNSS interference source over Europe by gpm on Friday June 05, 2026 @09:35AM (#48412355)
90% of starlink satellites are >400km in altitude. They aren't in very low earth orbits where that intuition even might be correct. They're above the space station.

I've definitely seen math done - though I'd have to dig it up again. I think in FAA filings.

Re:Tracing a powerful GNSS interference source over Europe by throwaway2037 on Monday June 15, 2026 @06:30AM (#48539260)
I agree with part of your response.

The best sources that I can find say that Starlink sats orbit around 550 km above Earth. By all accounts, this distance is well within Low Earth Orbit definitions. However, you used the term "very low earth orbits". I never heard before and needed to research it. It is a neologism from 2017 and does not seem to have a precise definition. Most uses indicate less than 450 km above Earth.

The International Space Station flies around 400 km above Earth.

Re:Tracing a powerful GNSS interference source over Europe by wiml on Friday June 05, 2026 @03:03PM (#48416786)
LEO is crowded enough (mostly with Starlink) that satellites have to actively maneuver to avoid collisions [1]. There's research [2] arguing that we're probably already in runaway territory in some orbits — that is, debris from 1 collision likely produces more than one secondary collision — we're just way over on the left of the hockey stick curve. A bit of bad luck, or two megaconstellations that don't perfectly coordinate their operations with each other, could move us to the right pretty quickly.

[1] https://arxiv.org/abs/2512.09643

[2] https://conference.sdo.esoc.esa.int/proceedings/sdc9/paper/3...

Re:Tracing a powerful GNSS interference source over Europe by db48x on Friday June 05, 2026 @06:58AM (#48410714)
No, Kessler syndrome is pretty unlikely in this case. All of the guilty satellites are in Molniya orbits. Debris from destroying them would not greatly effect geosynchronous orbit or the low earth orbits used by Starlink.
Re:Tracing a powerful GNSS interference source over Europe by Aerroon on Friday June 05, 2026 @06:58AM (#48410710)
I've thought about this before - do you actually need to "shoot it down" (make it explode)? What if you just nudge it a little and either make it spin or change its orbit? If your missile can reach the satellite then these seem like things that should be possible, no?
Re:Tracing a powerful GNSS interference source over Europe by Cthulhu_ on Friday June 05, 2026 @07:24AM (#48410923)
Depends, if you nudge it only a little, its own onboard stabilizers / thrusters should be able to correct it. It'd have to be more than its own systems can correct for.
Re:Tracing a powerful GNSS interference source over Europe by speed_spread on Friday June 05, 2026 @07:43AM (#48411083)
Nudge it long enough to deplete it's fuel reserves? Or just wrap the emitting antenna in tin foil...
Re:Tracing a powerful GNSS interference source over Europe by sroussey on Friday June 05, 2026 @01:29PM (#48415648)
There are tug boat style satellites now, one could grab it and force it to Earth.
Re:Tracing a powerful GNSS interference source over Europe by colechristensen on Friday June 05, 2026 @04:34PM (#48417837)
A missile intercept for explosions or a kinetic destruction the relative velocity will be measured in kilometers per second.

A little nudge doesn't do much, it's still a satellite in a substantially similar orbit. Any sort of nudge requires intercept, go up there and match its velocity so you can grab it and push. And still you have to push on it a whole lot to make a meaningful difference. Spin it up? You'd have to do enough to exhaust it's fuel it uses to orient itself.

You're sort of saying if you can chuck an apple hitting a car on the highway, surely you can tow it away to get it off the road. They're significantly different problems.

Re:Tracing a powerful GNSS interference source over Europe by Aerroon on Saturday June 06, 2026 @05:34AM (#48423109)
An apple at highway speeds can break the windshield and make the car undriveable. People throwing things from highway overpasses is a serious (and deadly) problem.

>A missile intercept for explosions or a kinetic destruction the relative velocity will be measured in kilometers per second.

The satellite will also be going kilometers per second. You have to almost match the orbital velocity to have a chance of hitting it anyway.

Re:Tracing a powerful GNSS interference source over Europe by colechristensen on Saturday June 06, 2026 @11:47AM (#48426125)
To the contrary, for the 1 satellite missile strike we have public information on, not only did it not catch up to the orbital velocity for intercept, it hit it head on (going the other direction) adding to the relative velocity. A satellite with an ~8 km/s orbital velocity was struck head on by a missile adding to that by ~2 km/s for a total just under 10 km/s.

It is indeed not that hard to intercept something in orbit. Because the orbits don't change and can be predicted to high precision months in the future.

Re:Tracing a powerful GNSS interference source over Europe by Aerroon on Saturday June 13, 2026 @07:25AM (#48516130)
I see. I'm actually more impressed by a head on intercept for the current anti-satellite missiles and that definitely makes the idea unworkable.
Re:Tracing a powerful GNSS interference source over Europe by ajsnigrutin on Friday June 05, 2026 @06:44PM (#48419301)
If you americans start shooting down russian stuff, russians start shooting down american stuff, and there's only chinese stuff left.