Re:Artificial intelligence is not conscious – Ted Chiang
by cauch on Friday June 05, 2026 @09:59AM
(#48412685)
Well, then you basically agree with Chiang's article. Just that Chiang as a clever usage of the word "understanding" than you (more clever because more nuanced: 1) I doubt that "people on the street" will agree that obviously "brainless" objects, like a pocket calculator or an interactive wikipedia page will understands anything, 2) Chiang is not stumbling on words: he explained his case that makes clear what he means, and it is to the interlocutor to adopt his vocabulary (because it is very legitimate here) rather than start saying "hm, no, I disagree, because for me, 'conscious' means 'print something on the screen', so LLMs are conscious". That is just missing the point)
I don't think that LLMs as black boxes are fundamentally novel, I just think that their internal design is novel, and their generality and ability to give correct responses to complex topics is far beyond anything previously. For example I would argue that wolfram alpha has a poor understanding of language and a very good understanding of math. I would argue that LLMs have an excellent understanding of language and a mediocre understanding of math, but are able to temporarily increase their understanding of math through document retrieval and "thinking" (or whatever you want to call the process of iteratively generating tokens that build on each other to result in a final response).