Ha, Sir Michael Atiyah's advice to a young mathematician includes a great anecdote: ""J. E. Littlewood is reported to have set each of his research students to work on a disguised version of the Riemann hypothesis, letting them know what he had done only after six months. He argued that the student would not have the confidence to attack such a famous problem directly, but might make progress if not told of the fame of his opponent! The policy may not have led to a proof of the Riemann hypothesis, but it certainly led to resilient and battle-hardened students"".
What a great story — sounds like it just leapt off the pages of the McSweeny's list "Zen Parable or Just Someone Being Cruel?".
Re:Advice to a Young Mathematician [pdf]
by eb007 on Tuesday November 27, 2012 @07:14PM
(#4840134)
love it... probably not intended but i found it fascinating how the description of finding new ideas and approaches in mathematics (or any field for that matter) is similar to that in startups. this part in particular resonated
"If you keep asking yourself such questions when
reading a paper or listening to a lecture, then sooner or
later a glimmer of an answer will emerge—some possible route to investigate. When this happens to me I
always take time out to pursue the idea to see where
it leads or whether it will stand up to scrutiny. Nine
times out of ten it turns out to be a blind alley, but
occasionally one strikes gold. The difficulty is in knowing when an idea that is initially promising is in fact
going nowhere. At this stage one has to cut one’s losses
and return to the main road. Often the decision is not
clear-cut, and in fact I frequently return to a previously
discarded idea and give it another try"
Re:Advice to a Young Mathematician [pdf]
by elteto on Tuesday November 27, 2012 @08:20PM
(#4840428)
I would like to archive this so that I can go back to it later, however I can't seem to find the original work and scribd is holding it hostage asking for a signup as ransom. Can anybody point me out to the source?
Re:Advice to a Young Mathematician [pdf]
by tokenadult on Tuesday November 27, 2012 @08:47PM
(#4840535)
I would like to archive this so that I can go back to it later, however I can't seem to find the original work and scribd is holding it hostage asking for a signup as ransom.
The original source (Princeton University Press) URL
appears if you mouse over the submission title here. I never read on scribd, which always annoys me with usability issues like that. But, alas, any user of HN who submits a .PDF link will find it automatically styled to also link to scribd.
Re:Advice to a Young Mathematician [pdf]
by alter8 on Wednesday November 28, 2012 @08:36PM
(#4845837)
Why? They're not that large, just click the original title instead. I would understand if you asked for a Google Cache replacement, though (I use a bookmarklet for that).
Re:Advice to a Young Mathematician [pdf]
by cschmidt on Tuesday November 27, 2012 @08:53PM
(#4840557)
The link was direct when I tried it. However, to answer your question, it is a chapter from The Princeton Companion to Mathematics. An amazing work covering much of mathematics.
The career for pure mathematicians(which is more like the humanities, and specific knowledge quite untransferrable) in academia, being better or worse, is open for discussion.
Re:Advice to a Young Mathematician [pdf]
by mitchi on Wednesday November 28, 2012 @01:26AM
(#4841286)
Quite questionable examples. Most girls I know become teachers/nurses/psychology/doctors and a few engineers. Zero in CS usually. It's only about the money in the US because your diploma costs too much money and you need to pay down your debt. His webpage only applies to the US, I'm sure other countries like Russia have babes in Computer Science (See Golden Eye).
Ha, Sir Michael Atiyah's advice to a young mathematician includes a great anecdote: ""J. E. Littlewood is reported to have set each of his research students to work on a disguised version of the Riemann hypothesis, letting them know what he had done only after six months. He argued that the student would not have the confidence to attack such a famous problem directly, but might make progress if not told of the fame of his opponent! The policy may not have led to a proof of the Riemann hypothesis, but it certainly led to resilient and battle-hardened students"".
What a great story — sounds like it just leapt off the pages of the McSweeny's list "Zen Parable or Just Someone Being Cruel?".
"If you keep asking yourself such questions when reading a paper or listening to a lecture, then sooner or later a glimmer of an answer will emerge—some possible route to investigate. When this happens to me I always take time out to pursue the idea to see where it leads or whether it will stand up to scrutiny. Nine times out of ten it turns out to be a blind alley, but occasionally one strikes gold. The difficulty is in knowing when an idea that is initially promising is in fact going nowhere. At this stage one has to cut one’s losses and return to the main road. Often the decision is not clear-cut, and in fact I frequently return to a previously discarded idea and give it another try"
The original source (Princeton University Press) URL
http://press.princeton.edu/chapters/gowers/gowers_VIII_6.pdf
appears if you mouse over the submission title here. I never read on scribd, which always annoys me with usability issues like that. But, alas, any user of HN who submits a .PDF link will find it automatically styled to also link to scribd.
http://www.amazon.com/Princeton-Companion-Mathematics-Timoth...
'Don't become a scientist!': http://wuphys.wustl.edu/~katz/scientist.html 'Women in science': http://philip.greenspun.com/careers/women-in-science
The career for pure mathematicians(which is more like the humanities, and specific knowledge quite untransferrable) in academia, being better or worse, is open for discussion.