News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Artificial intelligence is not conscious – Ted Chiang by felipeerias on Wednesday June 03, 2026 @07:50PM (#48391749)
What are you, ultimately, if not your body?
Re:Artificial intelligence is not conscious – Ted Chiang by margalabargala on Wednesday June 03, 2026 @07:56PM (#48391803)
I don't know. I also don't see how that changes the question. What is an AI, ultimately, without its computer hardware?
Re:Artificial intelligence is not conscious – Ted Chiang by felipeerias on Wednesday June 03, 2026 @09:06PM (#48392424)
Hardware is fungible. Each LLM response in a conversation could be served from a different machine.

Would you be "you" in a different body?

Re:Artificial intelligence is not conscious – Ted Chiang by margalabargala on Wednesday June 03, 2026 @09:33PM (#48392582)
Human bodies are fungible. I think I would be "me" in a different body, yes. So is anybody.

To claim otherwise would mean anyone who's gotten a transplant or amputation is no longer themselves.

Re:Artificial intelligence is not conscious – Ted Chiang by confidantlake on Wednesday June 03, 2026 @10:55PM (#48393118)
What most people think of as "me" is a product of their brain. If you somehow could get a brain transplant you certainly would not be "you".
Re:Artificial intelligence is not conscious – Ted Chiang by margalabargala on Wednesday June 03, 2026 @11:20PM (#48393325)
Sure, if you remove the brain or delete the weights then the human or LLM are different than they were.
Re:Artificial intelligence is not conscious – Ted Chiang by Jensson on Thursday June 04, 2026 @12:15PM (#48400778)
> Sure, if you remove the brain or delete the weights then the human or LLM are different than they were.

If you delete the hardware and buy new hardware and write in the same weights its still the same LLM. If you delete your brain, get a new brain and put in the same weights in the neurons its a clone, its not you. We know what happens when we create a clone, the clones aren't the same person they are separate consciousness, so consciousness is tied to the hardware.

Re:Artificial intelligence is not conscious – Ted Chiang by margalabargala on Thursday June 04, 2026 @02:44PM (#48402898)
> If you delete your brain, get a new brain and put in the same weights in the neurons its a clone, its not you.

Your whole argument hinges on this, and I don't think it's true.

A clone is not what you describe, not even close. Clones are copies of DNA, not of the actual physical neuron structures.

If you were to vanish, and the next moment a perfect atom-for-atom, particle-for-particle, quark-for-quark copy appear in exactly the same place, I think that is you. As far as I know, that does happen every single planck second.

For it to be you, though, it needs to occupy the same space you were previously in. You can't copy your atoms 5 times over in 5 different locations; those aren't you, they're just similar. Like copying an LLM 5 times over to different hardware, seeding its RNG differently each time.

Re:Artificial intelligence is not conscious – Ted Chiang by felipeerias on Wednesday June 03, 2026 @10:26PM (#48392908)
What, exactly, would be the link between you as you are right now, and “you” in a different body?
Re:Artificial intelligence is not conscious – Ted Chiang by margalabargala on Wednesday June 03, 2026 @11:28PM (#48393382)
Well, you'll have to tell me. Your question depends on your choice of language meaning.

If "I" am in a different body, then what makes that "me" who's in a different body?

Re:Artificial intelligence is not conscious – Ted Chiang by foltik on Thursday June 04, 2026 @12:24AM (#48393822)
From a functionalist perspective, there is no “you” sitting in one body or another.

The experience of “you” is just your specific memories and world model, continuously updated with sensory input.

If another body “runs” the same exact pattern, that is you. Theres no link and nothing was transferred; the pattern of thoughts and memories is all “you” ever was.

Same as playing the same song on two different speakers. Nobody asks what links the song across them; it’s the same song wherever it’s played. You’re just a far more complicated pattern on a far more complicated speaker.

You might ask, “but why am I this pattern?” Because this is the specific pattern modeling itself from the inside in asking that question.

Re:Artificial intelligence is not conscious – Ted Chiang by felipeerias on Thursday June 04, 2026 @02:25AM (#48394778)
The question is whether you can separate that “same exact pattern” from the physical body where it is taking place.

And my intuition is that no, you can’t, they are two aspects of the same reality.

Re:Artificial intelligence is not conscious – Ted Chiang by maxerickson on Wednesday June 03, 2026 @09:37PM (#48392590)
Of course they are themselves. The question is whether they are a different self.
Re:Artificial intelligence is not conscious – Ted Chiang by margalabargala on Wednesday June 03, 2026 @09:55PM (#48392690)
The answer to that can be anything anyone would like it to be, depending on what definition of "self" they choose.

I don't see why hardware is any more fungible than a kidney. If your LLM reads the serial numbers of its motherboard/RAM/etc as a seed for entropy you can make identical arguments about body fungibility and self.