News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Circle of Fifths, Part One by gnaritas on Monday November 26, 2012 @10:59AM (#4832467)
You might think that, you'd be wrong. I know what a relative minor is, I play guitar daily. I can play up and down the circle of fifths/fourths and improvise endlessly over the harmonized major/minor scale playing right through the changes. None of that knowledge helps decipher the purpose or meaning of the instructions you gave.

I'll try and walk through it.

> If "major" then switch to the relative minor, or vice versa.

OK, home chord is Em, so we'll use G major.

> Go Round the circle of fifths or the circLe of fourths either direction, but stay on whichever side of "major/minor."

OK, that's C or D given G as the starting point.

> Go up or down the scale, staying on whichever side of "major/minor."

So playing the G, C, or D scale over an E minor progression. G makes sense, same scale as Em; C or D... don't even parse for me. I don't think of chords and scales as separate, changing the scale changes the underlying chords I'd play under them, thus changing the key to something other than Em.

> So for example, a tune set with E minor, G major, A major should work.

What? Nothing you just said would lead me to think A major would work over an Em progression. G major, sure, obvious, it's the relative major of Em and just another name for G major scale, but A... why A, you haven't explained that above, your example doesn't match what the instructions seem to say.

Re:The Circle of Fifths, Part One by stcredzero on Monday November 26, 2012 @11:30AM (#4832612)
Then what you don't understand is how a trad tune set works. What I'm talking about is how to put together a set of three tunes that work well as one track on an album or one "number" in a performance. Each tune internally has its own progression, which may be different. I'm only talking about the home chord of each tune. (Which I state.)
Re:The Circle of Fifths, Part One by gnaritas on Monday November 26, 2012 @11:50AM (#4832713)
Well that clears up basically nothing; I still don't understand what you're saying, or where the A major comes in.
Re:The Circle of Fifths, Part One by stcredzero on Monday November 26, 2012 @12:57PM (#4833010)
A certain level of density is indistinguishable from trolling.
Re:The Circle of Fifths, Part One by gnaritas on Monday November 26, 2012 @01:13PM (#4833096)
True, but I wasn't. You really weren't as clear as you seem to think you were. If all you're saying is pick as roots nearby notes on the circle of fifths, you could have been much clearer.