Further commentary reveals that the people who have backed this guy are happy that he is the real deal, and that the problem has mostly stemmed from English being his second language, leading to a mis-communication over quite what part they had in manufacturing arduinos in Italy.
http://tcattorney.typepad.com/ip/2008/06/what-are-common.htm...
Are you suggesting there is a simple resolution to this set of law conflicts, and the answer is "it's not okay"?
Note besides the issue that there may be many countries involved, the company may also own different trademark rights in different countries.
Trademark law is only mildly harmonious and different countries definitely have very different fair use.
Who decides?
What are the rules for this decision?
etc
The problem is you are basically suggesting they set up an alternative judicial system. Outside of doing it with alternative dispute resolution methods (IE arbitration, mediation, etc), this is a really bad idea. ;)
Perhaps they could implement a 'Flag' system, that allows IP owners to signal illegal use/infringement, after which a review (in which both the complainer and the starter should be involved) can decide whether or not the project can proceed. This could easily sail into DCMA hell or lawyer heaven if a big corporation feels threatened, which could file complaint after complaint just to stall the competition.
But where do you draw the line?