Re:An ABC proof too tough even for mathematicians
by cbr on Monday November 26, 2012 @08:24AM
(#4831798)
We're talking theory, so imagine we have extremely powerful hardware, gobs of memory, understand the brain really well, and have some sort of extremely high-resolution scanning device. We could build an "emulator" that would simulate the brain's "hardware" and then load a scan of someone's brain onto it as "software". The system as a whole is just a big computer running a sophisticated program but it's equivalent to a human mind. This mind running on a computer would have the same strengths and
weaknesses as the mind had when running on a biological brain when it comes to determining the truth values of propositions in arithmetic (and everywhere else).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:An ABC proof too tough even for mathematicians
by leephillips on Monday November 26, 2012 @09:32AM
(#4832049)
To say that a computer program can not, in principle, do what the mind does is not to say that the mind can not exist on a substrate other than the familiar biological one. In your thought experiment the "software" would not be a computer program as we understand it; it would not be a set of algorithms. Also, it is problematic to separate "hardware" and "software", and to define what a "scan" of the brain might be.