Re:New York Passes Tax on the Ultra-Wealthy
by orangecat on Thursday May 28, 2026 @02:18PM
(#48313173)
Are gifts morally wrong? If I'm near death is it wrong for to give my assets to my children beforehand, or does it only become immoral if done via a will?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:New York Passes Tax on the Ultra-Wealthy
by kelseyfrog on Thursday May 28, 2026 @04:00PM
(#48314581)
Yes. I get the desire, but gifts of wealth when done at scale contribute to the destruction of society. Quantity is a quality all its own.
> Are gifts morally wrong?
If we're going to talk about morality, I think we need to talk about the government as one of the moral actors.
Imagine this scenario, exaggerated to make a point:
1. Alice receives $X. It's from her boss, for laboring in the mines every day. Government man says: "Give me 20% to pay for the shared roads, or you go to jail."
2. Bob receives $X. It's from his parents, for doing nothing other than being born related to them. Government man says: "Gee, I just can't do anything here, I guess I'll have to shake down Alice even harder next time."
Isn't there something off about the morality of Government Man's choices?